Feed
Pre Order FM2017 now. Get a FREE copy of FM Touch 2017 & BETA Access. Have you got FM2016 yet? Make sure to download these essential add ons! 1 minute ago
Ado77 commented on a data change for Tomas Kucera
12 minutes ago
Ado77 commented on a data change for Calum Chambers
18 minutes ago
timtim11 commented on: Facepacks Release thread - NO REQUESTS
21 minutes ago
Mateee commented on a data change for Danny Parker
1 hour ago
Kruna commented on: Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
1 hour ago
BajaHater commented on: Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
1 hour ago
fab88 commented on: Megapack - Missing image request thread
1 hour ago
A new version of our data update was released with 1872215 changes from 504 contributors.
1 hour ago
A new version of our data update was released with 906214 changes from 499 contributors.
1 hour ago
CountVladimir commented on: Megapack - Missing image request thread
2 hours ago
Mateee commented on a data change for Radek Zaloudek
2 hours ago
Vercoe commented on: The England National Team
3 hours ago
u-78 commented on: Standard Fantasy/Request Logo only (NO PACKS) Thread
3 hours ago
Suffolk Seasider commented on: 2016/17 Europa League
3 hours ago
WhiteH commented on: Restoration of the standard logos!
4 hours ago
Suffolk Seasider commented on: The England National Team
4 hours ago
BA81 commented on: Restoration of the standard logos!
4 hours ago
Suffolk Seasider commented on: The Night Thread Mk. IX
4 hours ago
WhiteH commented on: Restoration of the standard logos!
4 hours ago
alexis45 commented on: Russia - Premier Legaue SS'2016/17 New! (18/08/16)
4 hours ago
Sam commented on: FIFA 17
5 hours ago
Dan commented on: The England National Team
6 hours ago
WhiteH commented on: Restoration of the standard logos!
7 hours ago
BA81 commented on: Restoration of the standard logos!
7 hours ago
BananaRama2000 commented on: New season fixtures not loading
9 hours ago
Ernesttico commented on: Megapack - Missing image request thread
12 hours ago
bmg033 commented on: FIFA 17
13 hours ago
A new version of our data update was released with 1872223 changes from 503 contributors.
13 hours ago
A new version of our data update was released with 906228 changes from 499 contributors.
13 hours ago
chris commented on: 3D Official Kits Thread
Football Manager 2014 features a new and more realistic transfer system. For the first time ever you’ll be able to negotiate transfers in the same way as you could negotiate contracts in FM2013, using an instant ‘live’ system. Essentially you will be able to choose the value of your bid and add various clauses just as you would in Football Manager 2013, but now you can get an instant reply from the club you’re negotiating with. This is will no doubt be seen as a big improvement on previous versions of the game where you would have to wait days if not weeks for a reply, potentially missing out on other potential targets in the meantime, nonetheless it is not yet clear exactly what effect this change will have on the ability to sign players in Football Manager 2014.

I imagine that the thinking behind this new feature is twofold. There is of course the usability side of things. It’s going to be a lot easier and faster to negotiate transfers using the new system and the frustration associated with waiting days only to be knocked back will be long gone. There’s also a sense of realism with this new feature, it’s clearly attempting to replicate a real-life scenario in which two clubs sit around a table and have a live conversation regarding a transfer. Then again, you only need to look at the drawn out transfer dealings of this summer, such as Gareth Bale’s protracted transfer from Spurs to Real Madrid, to see that such negotiations aren’t always the norm.

It is perhaps for this reason that Sports Interactive have decided to include this new live system alongside the old transfer system, rather than replacing it completely. So in FM2014 you’ll have the option of whether to just make a normal bid or to use the new “Suggest Terms” button which will instigate the new live transfer system. The question remains however, what different this will make. Will AI clubs react differently to making an offer and waiting for a reply compared to using the new live system?

Recent versions of Football Manager have included the option to set a deadline for clubs to respond to transfer offers. Often setting a short deadline merely results in a refutation by the receiving club that they won’t be forced into making a quick decision, but sometimes it can be used to unsettle a player or club, enticing them to accept a lower offer, or pushing the deal through quicker if you’re in a hurry. Judging by the screenshots, which you can find below, the option to set a deadline still exists so it will be interesting to see how making an offer with a short deadline is different from instigating a live transfer, both in regards to the speed of completing a transfer and enticing a club to accept. There is a risk that the ability to set a deadline will become somewhat redundant if you can always opt for a live transfer instead.

While we still haven’t been given much information one screenshot seems to suggest that the live transfer system is less feature rich than it may at first appear. As you’ll see below it looks like an offer has been made for Stevenage Boroughs, Luke Freeman. In the next screenshot you’ll see that the message at the top has changed to “Stevenage have rejected the offer for Luke Freeman” and the two buttons “Make Offer” and “Suggest Terms” have been disabled. This implies that if a club rejects your suggestion of terms, you can’t immediately make an improved offer. If this is the case then the effectiveness of the live transfer system will be severely reduced. Presumably you will only be able to have a live transfer if the opposing club wishes to negotiate and tell you what terms they are interested in. If however they don’t wish to tell you their preferred terms then you’ll have to wait for another day to make another offer just as you would in previous versions of Football Manager. Perhaps this is the most realistic solution, as we’ve already said, not all transfers are beaten out around a table, some drag on for weeks or months with the receiving team refusing to negotiate until an offer becomes too good to turn down. While Sports Interactive have yet to make clear exactly how the new live transfer system works, it seems to me that this is the most likely implementation they’ll have gone for. Exactly how it works and what effect it will have on manager transfer dealings however… well we’ll have to wait and see.

http://sortitoutsi.net/uploads/fm14/screenshots/28239Transfer_Negotiations-(1).png

http://sortitoutsi.net/uploads/fm14/screenshots/28240Transfer_Negotiations-(2).png

http://sortitoutsi.net/uploads/fm14/screenshots/28241Transfer_Negotiations-(3).png
Discussion
It's a good addition, in my opinion. It happens in real life.

The loan back option is a good addition too.
Login to post a comment

Login Register