The website has been updated for the 24/25 season including updated player attributes and club finances. To play with the same data you have to click this banner to download our Data Update.

Data Update Poll!

Hello, there is currently an important debate going on regarding how to manage the FM24 Data Update going forward, particularly in the case of modifying the ages and contract dates by 1 year. Please can you vote in the poll and join in the discussion.

Rubbish youth players

1,141 6

andyboy57

15 years ago

1 year ago

22 Jul 2015 19:04:34

I need help with my youth players coming through the ranks. To put it simply, they are pants!

All my scouts have scouting ability/potential of 18+.
My training facilities are state of the art
Top youth facilities
Youth level 1
Good junior coaching
Extensive youth recruitment.

My coaches are all pretty good, yet none of my youth players have more than 2 stars for potential. I'm in my 5th season and would expect a few players to start filtering through who would be able to make a breakthrough into my senior squad. Majority arent even good enough to get offered pro contracts.

Where am I going wrong?????

Franck

18 years ago

2 weeks ago

4,255

22 Jul 2015 21:18:10

First off, the star ratings "lie", they are based on things like the reputation of your club and the other players in your squad and don't necessarily show whether a player could develop into an option for your first team or not, especially if you are managing a very big club. The written assessment from your assistant in the player report is much more accurate, it'll rate potential using words like "world class", "star", "leading player" and "good player". "World class" is a guarantee that the player has a PA north of 180, the other ratings are relative to what league you are playing in.

andyboy57

15 years ago

1 year ago

22 Jul 2015 22:05:55

By Franck | On 22 July 2015 - 22:18 PM

First off, the star ratings "lie", they are based on things like the reputation of your club and the other players in your squad and don't necessarily show whether a player could develop into an option for your first team or not, especially if you are managing a very big club. The written assessment from your assistant in the player report is much more accurate, it'll rate potential using words like "world class", "star", "leading player" and "good player". "World class" is a guarantee that the player has a PA north of 180, the other ratings are relative to what league you are playing in.

Just went through my youth players. Still pants lol

Franck

18 years ago

2 weeks ago

4,255

22 Jul 2015 22:12:53

What club are you managing?

andyboy57

15 years ago

1 year ago

22 Jul 2015 22:38:52

By Franck | On 22 July 2015 - 23:12 PM

What club are you managing?

Newcastle. I'm halfway through my 4th season.

Sheriff Skacel

10 years ago

10 months ago

940

Premium

26 Jul 2015 07:36:49

This is due to a shortage of coal for little Geordie boys to be kicking around in the streets.

What is pants in your view too? A two star PA player can be tidy for an EPL club. Just ask yourself, how many youngsters have come through the Newcastle academy in the 21st century? Its a waiting game in FM just as it is in real life.

You'll need to Login to comment

Football Manager Skins

Football Manager Player Faces (4 Styles)

Football Manager Kits (4 Styles)

Football Manager Logos (15 Styles)

Football Manager Backgrounds (1 Styles)

Data Update Poll!

24/25 Season Update

FM Discord

YouTube