The website has been updated for the 24/25 season including updated player attributes and club finances. To play with the same data you have to click this banner to download our Data Update.

Scout reports, why do they change like that?

1,541 3

Ruudvangoal

17 years ago

1 year ago

28 Dec 2014 09:53:15

I am playing in my journeyman game and scout reports are mostly inaccurate and screwed up, for example i signed Aleksander Mitrovic for my Marseille team he scored 46 in 35 games and was CL best player and scorer and my scout who had 20 judging both CA and PA gave him 4 stars, later when i moved to city my scouts who have similar stats are saying he is 2.5 stars CA and PA despite him scoring in every game, same with Odegaard he was 4 yello + black and when i moved to city he became 3.5 despite having amazing stats, and exactly the same thing happened with Manual Lucatelli.

Are they screwed up? do you really rely on scout ratings?

Tyrion Lannister

12 years ago

5 years ago

1,536

Banned

1 Warning

28 Dec 2014 22:25:22

I am guessing you're not English? ill try to decipher and answer.
okay ill keep it simple.

scouts change with what team they work for and so do players star ratings. hence, a player can be 2 stars but can progress to more if they play well.
a scouts knowledge of a player improves also. a scouts interpretation of a player changes with every club he scouts for.

if I have a scout with JPP & JPA at 20 for real Madrid and I look at mitrovic it rates him at 2.5, then it rates him at how much he will be good enough for them!

if I employ the same scout for say, QPR, then I dare say it will up that to 4 stars...

boriz13

15 years ago

11 months ago

03 Jan 2015 15:55:03

Yeah, it depends on the team you manage. Smaller team usually gives higher ratings, while in bigger team the same player get lower rating. The best example would be Alex Song, in Barca he was a rotation player while in West Ham he's one of their best midfielder. Therefore in West Ham his rating would be around 4 stars, while in Barca his rating would be only around 2 stars.

You'll need to Login to comment

Football Manager Skins

Football Manager Player Faces (4 Styles)

Football Manager Kits (4 Styles)

Football Manager Logos (15 Styles)

Football Manager Backgrounds (1 Styles)

24/25 Season Update

FM Discord

Twitter