Sir William - Comments

#360831 Marvin Zeegelaar
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
It's debatable whether this would be an improvement

As posted elsewhere for a similar reason, the current megapack image was only created a couple of months or so ago and it's cut from a high-quality source. While your source is good (and I wish all players had source images as good and easy to cut), I just don't see the point in having a slightly different cut to the existing megapack version and I would much rather see cutters spending time on genuine improvements and missing images.

Apart from the source quality, you should also keep in mind the existing megapack image when making a request. Just because it's a newer image doesn't necessarily mean it's an improvement. I'm not rejecting it, but I doubt whether I'd consider any resulting cut for inclusion into the MP. Just letting you know so you keep it in mind for any future requests


Thanks mons and I will take everything you said into consideration
#360772 Marvin Zeegelaar
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Already done somewhere at site,but not considered as improvement.Also,this is not even best available source.


Sorry about that, you wouldn't know where I could find it would you?
#347741 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Edit: Completed, thank you Bakizp
#347681 Official Teampack Request Thread - Read the OP before requesting
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Sporting Clube de Portugal 2016/2017

Example - https://scontent-mad.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/14316991_2109331192624541_28834829959595287_n.jpg?oh=3da761432bbf42c22ba869b1875d6541&oe=5885C5DA

#347000 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Baja Edit - Not an improvement.
#336539 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Player Name: Rui Patricio

Player ID: 55000929

Link: Link to picture

Existing Images: Search results for: 55000929


http://akacdn.transfermarkt.de/images/portrait/originals/45026-1445432335.jpg



Check the Portugal Euro 2016 pack
#336174 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Player Name: Islam Slimani

Player ID: 12031625

https://i.imgsafe.org/07aa7baf59.jpg

Existing Images: Search results for: 12031625

Thanks in advance
#335179 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Edit: No longer needed, thanks!
#335172 Facepacks Release thread - NO REQUESTS
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
#335065 Cut-Out Faces Megapack TECHNICAL SUPPORT thread - please read first post before posting
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
I think I can explain the Ben Arfa situation, he is a free agent and in your game he is possibly in the French National Team, all french players stop having cut-outs when they're playing for their country (I don't know why, but it's been that way ever since I remember).
#334981 Official Teampack Request Thread - Read the OP before requesting
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Anyone doing Portugal? just asking
#321965 Any other matters - related to Cut Outs but not to any particular thread
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
You're known over here as person who wants cuts just because they are from your favorite team or current season no matter are they improvements or not.In those 4 years his look didn't change a bit,current one is done from HQ source wich is far better than your crap UEFA source.


I come here so rarely, how can anyone have any complaints? and how is Naldo related to my team? (My request was for Wolfsburg's Naldo)
#321956 Any other matters - related to Cut Outs but not to any particular thread
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Only annoying thing are your none improvement requests.


That's your opinion... The picture I suggested is from this season as well as better, the current cut out is almost 4 years old.
#321933 Any other matters - related to Cut Outs but not to any particular thread
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Baja Edit - Not an improvement.


This is annoying.
#321927 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Baja Edit - Not an improvement.
#319032 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Baja Edit - Not an improvement.
#302924 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Player Name: Bruno Paulista

Player ID: 19247495

Link: Link to picture

Existing Images: Search results for: 19247495


Baja Edit - Already done and will be in next update.


Where is it? I can't seem to find it
#282715 Portugal Mixpack 27
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Is it possible to have the cut outs of Rui Patricio from the UEFA pics?
#269629 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Player Name: Carlos Mané

Player ID: 55024894

Link: Link to picture

Existing Images: Search results for: 55024894


Mons edit - Image has been cut
#265903 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Player Name: Carlos Mané

Player ID: 55024894

Link: Link to picture

Existing Images: Search results for: 55024894


https://fbcdn-sphotos-c-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-xfp1/v/t1.0-9/11156168_935056146516472_1702975238987458951_n.jpg?oh=6fd6946a0c10858392f9114eb717d0e4&oe=55CE8DA8&__gda__=1436049953_da45f4d277f661e45657d9c2e0fca675
#261620 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Player Name: Carlos Mané

Player ID: 55024894

Link: Link to picture

Existing Images: Search results for: 55024894


https://fbcdn-sphotos-c-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-xfp1/v/t1.0-9/11156168_935056146516472_1702975238987458951_n.jpg?oh=6fd6946a0c10858392f9114eb717d0e4&oe=55CE8DA8&__gda__=1436049953_da45f4d277f661e45657d9c2e0fca675
#244161 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Player Name: William Carvalho

Player ID: 55012106

Link: Link to picture

Existing Images: Search results for: 55012106


http://s7.postimg.org/w5gyh1xkn/55012106.png?noCache=1416861363
#224105 Any other matters - related to Cut Outs but not to any particular thread
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
I'm sorry but not a single one of those is remotely close to being a genuine improvement to the current MP image as they are just too small...


Maybe I didn't say what I meant to say correctly, what I was saying was that if anyone could locate the sources used they would all be improvements
#223705 Any other matters - related to Cut Outs but not to any particular thread
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
FUT15 (A game mode in FIFA15) uses cut outs for player cards, cut outs of photographs that I can not find anywhere, but that are too small for FM...

Here are the best cut outs on FUT15 that I am sure would be definite improvements, I am sharing this in hopes that anyone will find the sources used, because I can't.

Hugo Lloris: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/167948.png

Walker: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/188377.png

Fahrmann: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/179783.png

Meyer: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/212150.png

Gundogan: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/186942.png

Piszczek: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/173771.png

Reus: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/188350.png

Gotze: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/192318.png

Boateng: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/183907.png

Neuer: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/players/fifa13/167495.png

Nani: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/139068.png

Immobile: http://futhead.cursecdn.com/static/img/15/players/192387.png
#223703 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Player Name: Adrien

Player ID: 55001975

Existing Images: Search results for: 55001975

http://i1147.photobucket.com/albums/o560/pedrotavares1/adrien_zps90c6d1e1.png


To add to this request, I'd like to add

Player Name: John Terry
Player ID: 108625

Existing Images: Search results for: 108625

http://img.uefa.com/imgml/TP/players/1/2015/324x324/45902.jpg
#222037 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
#221982 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
I think this could be a good replacement if someone can remove the watermark

Player Name: Marco Silva

Player ID: 7003860

Link: Link to picture

Existing Images: Search results for: 7003860


https://sortitoutsi.net/uploads/mirrored_images/QV26Nh5YC9VhIcaUUqjoIqUsfhXy49pkDZ7yyETN.jpg


His cutout from the UEFA pics (available in the Portugal mix pack 23 by Andr3) is better
#221911 Official Teampack Request Thread - Read the OP before requesting
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
Is anybody doing Chelsea and Dortmund's cut outs?
#221861 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
#221200 Megapack - Improvement Image request thread - NEW RULES IN OP
Sir William
13 years ago
1 year ago
142
(Accidentally posted twice, my bad)