legionaire
15 years ago
2 months ago
3

legionaire - Comments

Comments
#854260 Brazilian Men's and Women's League – Complete Mega Pack (Includes 2D Kits & Logos)
legionaire
15 years ago
2 months ago
3
18 Nov 2025 20:21:53

Without state leagues, shouldn't this be uploaded as fictional league instead of real league? 

#852214 Chinese Super League : Data fix
legionaire
15 years ago
2 months ago
3
11 Nov 2025 19:00:38
By Shoshoko 11 November 2025 - 18:10 PM UTC 

For player ratings, I based my assessment on: market values, performances, strengths and weaknesses noted by analysis sites, FMinside, and comparisons with other leagues (League 2 and National 1).

Many players increase with minor attribute increases or new positions.

Normally, key attributes are low and they should therefore perform poorly abroad (coolness, vision of the game, etc.). Wei Zhen and Zhang Linpeng are the best examples, with small additions (particularly physical for Wei Zhen) that increase significantly. Or Malele and Asue, who are weak technically but better physically. This has increased their value.

The problem with the Chinese league is that Transfermarkt market values are too volatile. This also highlights the weakness of the league. But given the ratings of certain National 1 players, for example, I don't think the ratings are too high. Especially given the conditions.

Another major problem with the Chinese league is the lack of comparison with foreign leagues, which makes it difficult to give accurate ratings, other than in the ACL, where Chinese teams field their B teams.

Finally, some foreign players are not that strong and are sometimes weaker than foreign players. If I could make a general change, I would lower all players (including foreigners) by 10 points. I think that once in China, foreigners lower their standards level. 

For Wang Shenchao, he's just horrible. 

This is a friendly project made by players and for player. So, if you have any other objections, opinions, ideas, etc., please do not hesitate to share them. I will gladly take them into consideration.

 

Well, my opinion is based on watching them play, Asue is not very physical, he only has 60-70 minutes stamina under Shenhua's high intensity playstyle, not as fast as Mineiro or as strong as Malele, so his current physical attribute is mostly fine, could use a little increase but bumping him to 126ca would make him score a lot with Shenhua's strong midfield, which doesn't happen irl. Malele's physical could get +1, which shouldn't cost 13ca.

 

For Port's defenders, Wang perform better than Wei and Zhang, he also has decent attacking capability, with Port almost sealed another champion despite Oscar and Vargas left the club and Wu Lei injured, decreasing their starting rb and increasing sub cb is very confusing to me.

 

For overall rating, while it's ok to bump some Chinese players, especially youngsters as youth teams perform a lot better comparing to 10 years ago, but considering CSL team's performance in ACL, you can't make top teams better than Johor and Buriram (these two has starting 11 mostly 110-125ca), which is why I suggest capping most of top Chinese player around 100-110 to maintain balance on the east group, unless you are going to adjust Thailand and Malaysia league as well.

 

In case you think they fielded weaker team, they didn't in last season. This season ACL elite they only fielded weaker team in 1st and 3rd round (Shenhua didn't rotate this round), and with Beijing's rotation lineup performed abysmally in ACL 2, you can't really rate them very high.

#852022 Chinese Super League : Data fix
legionaire
15 years ago
2 months ago
3
11 Nov 2025 09:12:14

Asue definitely does not deserve big increase, otherwise champion would be Shenhua instead of Port, the same can be said for Malele.

 

Decrease Wang Shenchao but increase Wei Shen and Zhang Linpeng is also questionable imo.

 

And Chinese player other than Wu Lei, national GKs and 3 CBs shouldn't go above 110, it would make them on-par with foreigners, which is not how it is irl.