Do remember to crop closer to the chin, nudging the collar up if needed @Cizzu 👍

Yes, but It's a temporary cut. I'm looking for an even more recent photo.

 

Temporary or not, if it's uploaded to here, it's important that cuts follow the guidelines 👍

Mons, they are indeed guidelines, not an imposition.
I've been doing cuts for 15 years, I don't think I need the guidelines anymore, don't you think? I would be a very serious case of recidivism. 😅 
 

However, it is important to preserve the morphology of the face and other parts of the body. If a person has a pronounced nose, do you shorten it? No. If he has protruding ears, do you correct them? No. Likewise, if a person has a longer neck than other people, it should be preserved, it is a characteristic of that person. We don't all have the same neck size. If you paid a little more attention, for example, already from the shape of the neck, you would probably be able to roughly guess the player's height. It's nice that this vague indication remains inside the cut.  👍🏻

The fact I have to keep reminding you about the guidelines means that you're not following them, irrespective of how long you've been cutting 😕

I have no idea of the point of the argument you're making, frankly. It's got nothing to do with the length of a person's neck. If a player is sitting, if a player is perching his head forward and if a player is craning his neck to one side, the image will look different. If you paid a little more attention, for example, the first cut for his player demonstrates that he does not, in fact, have a particularly long neck. We want to have a standardised megapack look as much as possible, with the collar being close to the chin, which is why the guideline/rule exists.