FM24 CA/PA and Attributes Updates

@Yuzo  @milenec11 it is live just download the latest version from here: https://sortitoutsi.net/football-manager-data-update 

The likes of Marmoush are still not updated though in this one

I think is because you dont had the classic update

I do. Can u check on yours if it’s different 

Mine is the same, and i see a lot of changes, including Brazil, names like Barcola, João Neves

Then I guess the changes are incomplete. Hopefully the next one fixes it

@Footygamer i have this version Classic FM the Enhanced Data Update including Dynamic Data 

i download the latgest nothing there still most missing

@Footygamer Please help us mate. I’m desperate to return to the game for a fresh save but some of the missing attribute changes make it less than inviting.

Mind ask what are the missing attributes mate? talking about especifiv players?

Generally, it seems like many EPL players haven't been upgraded. I glanced at City, Arsenal and Spurs players and many are lacking. Marmoush is the best example of this. His stats are trash and he ends up being loaned out to the likes of Aston Villa.

@Yuzo Marmoush had his CA updated from 135 to 160 which I think is pretty significant. 160 puts him in the top 41 players in the league alongside people like Luis Díaz, Kai Havertz and Anthony Gordon which I think is reasonable.

Unless there is some installation error or bug in some kind? 

I’ve downloaded the latest file but his CA is 135

There must be an issue with the file

@Yuzo 

The ability changes are in the “Non Dynamic Data” file.

In your screenshot you have not checked that file.

Thanks for pointing that out. It seems the file was clashing with another one I previously had one from Daveincid's realism pack. The issue is sorted now. Cheers!

Can you explain what the issue was with Daveincd's file? @Yuzo 

@Yuzo 

@Footygamer 

the issue with Dave’s packs are many but what works with sortitusti files or not without problem you have be patreon of his in order to learn it .

Only you @Footygamer can tell us before installing any file what we should tic and what no. I know for sure that you can not use any dynamic player file for example and others ….

@TheMinsterman @Footygamer Just noticed there are some heavily messed up CA's in Urawa Reds (J-League Japan). 

For example Samuel Gustafson has dropped from 137 to 92 and Marius Hoibraten from 124 to 86. Surely must be by mistake or some bug?

Gustafson was and should be their best player.

Makes me wonder how common these weird unrealistic CA changes are. Is this possible for you guys to check? 

I was really looking forward to start a new career now with your recent CA/PA and new player updates. Sadly I just can't use these updates after what I just discovered 😢 

Hey @Zoul thanks for reporting this, I will investigate and see if I can find out why he dropped so much

@Footygamer Thanks for the reply 🙂 Hopefully you can sort this out asap. 

Looked around a little more in J-League CA changes and there is more. Other examples are: Gaku Shibasaki, his CA has dropped to 87. He is a starting player for Kashima Antlers and has 60 caps for Japan. Yan Matheus, Yokohama F.M. dropped CA to 100, also a starting player with 75 J-League games to his resumé. 

Maybe all Japanese leagues are affected by these unrealistic changes? Would it be possible to just erase all Japanese CA/PA changes for the time being, until you have the time to sort it out properly?

https://www.transfermarkt.com/gaku-shibasaki/profil/spieler/129693

https://www.transfermarkt.com/yan-matheus/profil/spieler/323945

Hey @Zoul I have confirmed the issue/misunderstanding and will be updating the Japanese players, hopefully today.

I really appreciate you taking the time to report it in a friendly way and giving such a clear and helpful description with specific examples. You don't know how rare that is haha so genuinely thanks 🙂

@Footygamer Appreciate it mate 🙂 It also just hit me how much this site has given to elevate my FM experience year after year. I'm the one who should thank you and everyone that contributes.
 

Signed up for Premium memebership right now 🙂 THANKS!

It seems he has a file for CA and PA changes as well that includes new wonderkids. When using that with the CA/PA file from here, it essentially nullifies all attribute changes, so I'm simply not using that file from Dave now

when will non dynamic pa ca file update next time?

can we expect every month update?

It is so wrong that Mateta and Elanga has none improved ca/pa, they Are on fire this season..

@Footygamer I see that you fixed the Japanese CA's now. Game on! 😀 

Updates needed for Ajax:

• Youri Baas need 20 CB and 18 LB
• Jorthy Mokio need CA / PA update. CA above 120. PA above 165

One comment about Matheus Franca at Crystal Palace, he seems to get a PA of max 130-140 on every save I've checked, this is is too harsh, earlier databases (this year and last year) he has 160-170 on PA, same about David Ozoh at Crystal Palace, never reaches over 148 in PA, most often 120-130 I've tested this in 100's of saves to check because I know the data is dynamic and unique.

hi,

I also paid for the Classic Update in the hope that the players would have realistic values. It's clear that this doesn't work for everyone. But Marmoush at City only 3 stars ability and 135 potential and only worth 5.5m (in reality it's 60m)?

His last club wasn't Frankfurt either, but Wolfsburg in the game:-(

Or Barcelona... Gavi, Yamal and Rafinha only have 2.5 to 3 stars, they are already at world class level. The market values here are also far below reality...

Is this generally not realistically adjusted in the updates, at least for the star players?

Best,

Shadow

You are doing something wrong. Marmoush has 162 potencial in a quick search made from the 24-25 update database.