Slashman X
17 years ago
5 months ago
6,000
Premium
PSG have had their FFP punishment reduced to "only" a £20m fine paid over 3 years. No other sanctions.
Tommo.
12 years ago
1 year ago
2,272
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BdV0BBQCcAA94rL.jpg

Yaya to UFC confirmed


Could see him taking on Bones Jones
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
As much as Martin Samuels is an idiot I don't know how much credit Pellegrini really deserves.
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
1 day ago
5,082
Premium
As much as Martin Samuels is an idiot I don't know how much credit Pellegrini really deserves.

A lot. He's done the double in his first season in England and has had City playing some incredible football.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
A lot. He's done the double in his first season in England and has had City playing some incredible football.


And yet scraped over the line with easily the best squad in the country against one of the weakest field of challengers he could have hoped for.

Saying that, I think he's been a marked improvement on Mancini who would definitely have imploded and sulked after that Sunderland result.
The Platypus
13 years ago
1 year ago
1,784
It's been a weird season. Chelsea imploding during March and April, and Liverpool fucking up. None of the top teams have really been that impressive (which I know is a weird thing to say, when City and Liverpool have scored over 100 goals).
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
1 day ago
5,082
Premium
And yet scraped over the line with easily the best squad in the country against one of the weakest field of challengers he could have hoped for.

Saying that, I think he's been a marked improvement on Mancini who would definitely have imploded and sulked after that Sunderland result.

Nonsense. If you're going to be that petty then Ferguson's titles in the 1990's should be devalued given they comfortably had the most money and the best squad. If you win the league over 38 games then you deserve it and the acclaim that comes with it. City played some great stuff this year as well so given that this is his first season in the Premier League he has done a great job.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
Nonsense. If you're going to be that petty then Ferguson's titles in the 1990's should be devalued given they comfortably had the most money and the best squad. If you win the league over 38 games then you deserve it and the acclaim that comes with it. City played some great stuff this year as well so given that this is his first season in the Premier League he has done a great job.


Where did I say they've not deserved it?

Just that at various points over the season they've tried all tried very hard to throw it away, if Liverpool hadn't imploded over the past 2 weeks they'd have won it despite conceding 50,000 goals and if Chelsea could beat the dregs in the league they'd have won it too.

Obviously they've been the least inconsistent side, because thats why they've got the most points, but they've had their share of attempting to throw it away, too, drawing with Sunderland, for example.
Sam
17 years ago
1 year ago
5,092
Pellegrini has done a fantastic job to be honest.
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
1 day ago
5,082
Premium
Where did I say they've not deserved it?

Just that at various points over the season they've tried all tried very hard to throw it away, if Liverpool hadn't imploded over the past 2 weeks they'd have won it despite conceding 50,000 goals and if Chelsea could beat the dregs in the league they'd have won it too.

Obviously they've been the least inconsistent side, because thats why they've got the most points, but they've had their share of attempting to throw it away, too, drawing with Sunderland, for example.

You're being an incredibly harsh and keep ignoring the fact that it's first season in England and that he won the Capital One Cup as well. Oh, and that he did it all playing beautiful football. He's done a great job.

They've lost two games since November. They won the last five games in a row to clinch the title. They've scored an obscene number of goals. The end of this season may feel a bit anti-climatic after Liverpool's wheels fell off but if you're really going to try and downplay what a superb job he's done you're just going to come across as petty.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
You're being an incredibly harsh and keep ignoring the fact that it's first season in England and that he won the Capital One Cup as well. Oh, and that he did it all playing beautiful football. He's done a great job.

They've lost two games since November. They won the last five games in a row to clinch the title. They've scored an obscene number of goals. The end of this season may feel a bit anti-climatic after Liverpool's wheels fell off but if you're really going to try and downplay what a superb job he's done you're just going to come across as petty.


I don't really see why you think its petty to point out that he's in charge of the massive favourites and therefore winning the title was always basically expected.

All titles are equal, and he's clearly done pretty well, but all champions aren't and its far less impressive him winning the league with City than Rodgers having won it at Liverpool or if Simeone manages it at Atletico. His true test comes next season, for me.
VP.
13 years ago
1 month ago
25,271
I don't really see why you think its petty to point out that he's in charge of the massive favourites and therefore winning the title was always basically expected.

All titles are equal, and he's clearly done pretty well, but all champions aren't and its far less impressive him winning the league with City than Rodgers having won it at Liverpool or if Simeone manages it at Atletico. His true test comes next season, for me.


Well you did when i said exactly the same about Mourinho.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
Well you did when i said exactly the same about Mourinho.


I don't remember that, but Mourinho has had a torrid season in hindsight.
Slashman X
17 years ago
5 months ago
6,000
Premium
Fuck ye cunts. Watch this gloriousness

Poe
17 years ago
5 days ago
3,675
Fastest he's moved all season.
Slashman X
17 years ago
5 months ago
6,000
Premium
Saying Pellegrini doesn't deserve any credit for winning his 1st title in Europe in his 1st season in England is just ridiculous.

Drawing 1 game against Sunderland is hardly "trying to throw it away"
Slashman X
17 years ago
5 months ago
6,000
Premium
Tommo.
12 years ago
1 year ago
2,272
Fuck ye cunts. Watch this gloriousness



So majestic
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
1 day ago
5,082
Premium
I don't really see why you think its petty to point out that he's in charge of the massive favourites and therefore winning the title was always basically expected.

If that's the mentality you're going to take then a large number of Ferguson's titles should be devalued considering how often Manchester United were massive favourites and winning the title was basically expected.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
If that's the mentality you're going to take then a large number of Ferguson's titles should be devalued considering how often Manchester United were massive favourites and winning the title was basically expected.


Where did I say I was devaluing the title? I think my exact words were 'all titles are equal'.

All I'm saying is that as soon as it emerged that we weren't going to compete for the title this season everyone had City as nailed on favourites (and a great deal of people before even that), it was a title that Mancini probably could have delivered.

Until Pellegrini really shows he's taken City on to a better level, either through better European performances (I know Slash and bluemoon will point to the fact that they got out of their group this time, but those two legs against Barca were some of the weakest I've seen) or delivering titles when teams against them are mounting considerable pressure then I don't think he's due a great deal more credit than Mancini did, and that ended up with him getting the boot which is why next season with, presumably, a bigger challenge from Chelsea, Liverpool, Arsenal and (hopefully) us we'll gauge the true extent of where he is taking City.

Or, to give a different example, did Sebastian Vettel win 4 titles because he was the best driver, or was he a good driver in by far the best car? The evidence of this season will probably go furthest to shaping the answer to that question, but that doesn't mean he wasn't deserving of the 4 he did win. The same is true of this season for City, in my opinion.
Slashman X
17 years ago
5 months ago
6,000
Premium
He's playing far, far, far better football than Mancini ever did, and doing it consistently. That's why he's due more credit
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
1 day ago
5,082
Premium
Where did I say I was devaluing the title? I think my exact words were 'all titles are equal'.

All I'm saying is that as soon as it emerged that we weren't going to compete for the title this season everyone had City as nailed on favourites (and a great deal of people before even that), it was a title that Mancini probably could have delivered.

Until Pellegrini really shows he's taken City on to a better level, either through better European performances (I know Slash and bluemoon will point to the fact that they got out of their group this time, but those two legs against Barca were some of the weakest I've seen) or delivering titles when teams against them are mounting considerable pressure then I don't think he's due a great deal more credit than Mancini did, and that ended up with him getting the boot which is why next season with, presumably, a bigger challenge from Chelsea, Liverpool, Arsenal and (hopefully) us we'll gauge the true extent of where he is taking City.

Or, to give a different example, did Sebastian Vettel win 4 titles because he was the best driver, or was he a good driver in by far the best car? The evidence of this season will probably go furthest to shaping the answer to that question, but that doesn't mean he wasn't deserving of the 4 he did win. The same is true of this season for City, in my opinion.

You are devaluing the title win though because you're effectively saying he's getting too much credit for what he's done. I understand that Manchester City have the best side and should be winning it, but when you throw in the brand of football they play it becomes far more impressive. Also, even if they under perform slightly in Europe they lost to Barcelona who are probably the 3rd/4th best side in the continent right now. Hardly a disgrace.

Again, even the F1 description brings me back to my point about Ferguson - year after year he had the "best car" so using your analogy whether or not he was the "best driver" almost doesn't matter. Your points seems to revolve around City being the favourites to win it, therefore the credit Pellegirini gets should be downplayed, but as I've already said that means that a number of Ferguson's titles should be seen as such because Manchester United consistently had the best squad and in the 1990's were the richest club as well.

Also, as has been said, you can't ignore the fact that Pellegrini also won the Capital One Cup - doing the double in your first season as a Premier League manager is tough, regardless of who you are - and won both trophies playing a spectacular style of football. I'm not a fan of Manchester City by any stretch of the imagination but I struggle to understand how anyone could want to piss on his achievements given what he's done in his first campaign in England.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
So after 6 posts or whatever of exactly the same points neither of us are willing to budge from our points that is: Yours: 'Pellegrino has come into a new league and won two trophies playing good football so he deserves unreserved praise' and Mine: 'He's clearly done decently, but basically what was expected of him and it will be easier to judge next season quite how well he is doing/has done'.

There's no point discussing further because neither of us will budge, but the idea that a league title earns you a carte blanche from speculation about how good a job you're doing is a bit odd.

Oh and you keep mentioning the COC but it doesn't matter, no one really cares about it, and they had an unbelievably easy run to the final. He's not going to be disappointed they won it but there's bigger fish to fry and he will be judged on different criteria.
Slashman X
17 years ago
5 months ago
6,000
Premium
"Unreserved praise", or any praise like
Slashman X
17 years ago
5 months ago
6,000
Premium
bluemoon.
17 years ago
3 months ago
2,411
Premium
UEFA have announced the FFP sanctions: €60m fine (to be taken from any revenues from UEFA competitions from 2013/14 onwards) and a 21-man squad limit for next season's Champions League squad.

Having read the UEFA statement (here) it looks like the issue was the two IP sales rather than the Etihad deal.

The summary from City's website:

- MCFC will lose 10m Euros of its share of income from UEFA for competing in the Champions League completion in season 2013-14.
- MCFC will lose 10m Euros of its share of income from UEFA for competing in the Champions League for season 2014-15
- Rather than having an accumulative allowance of 30m Euros of losses over the next two reporting years (like all other clubs), MCFC will have specific stipulated allowances for 2013-14 and 2014-15 of 20m Euros and 10m Euros respectively. Significantly, MCFC plans to be profitable in 2014-15 and in the years that follow.
- The MCFC Champions League squad for the 2014-15 competition will be limited to 21 players. In 2013-14 the club registered 23 players for the competition and used 21.
- The Club’s expenditure on new players for the upcoming summer transfer window, on top of income from players it might sell, will be limited to 60m euros. This will have no material impact on the Club’s planned transfer activity.
- The wage bill of the whole club (playing and non-playing staff) for 2014-15 will need to remain at the same level as that of 2013-14 season. It is important to note that additional bonuses for performances can be paid outside this number. Importantly, in reality, the existing MCFC business plan sees a natural decline in that wage bill.
- Given the unique nature of the new City Football Group structure – which incorporates MCFC, New York City, Melbourne Heart and a number of other companies, the Club has agreed to certain non-material terms in order to make FFP reporting as easy as possible for UEFA to discern.
Slashman X
17 years ago
5 months ago
6,000
Premium
At the heart of those discussions is a fundamental disagreement between the Club’s and UEFA’s respective interpretations of the FFP regulations on players purchased before 2010. The Club believes it has complied with the FFP regulations on this and all other matters.


Apparently the fine will be reduced to 20m if City comply to some regulations.

2 good things from the club statement:
This will have no material impact on the Club’s planned transfer activity.

Importantly, in reality, the existing MCFC business plan sees a natural decline in that wage bill.
Slashman X
17 years ago
5 months ago
6,000
Premium
Only problem will be the homegrown quota in the CL. We need 8 homegrown out of 21
Carroll.
15 years ago
3 years ago
3,361
So they can get round the wage cap with bonuses

You'll need to Login to comment