buzzfest
13 years ago
3 weeks ago
6

Hi all,

 

I was wondering what the community thought about an update to the Medical/Physio function in FM about club medicals. 
 

IRL, medicals aren’t pass or fail, they are graded, often on a traffic light system. Green, no problems; amber, some risks; red, some serious risks. 
 

The level of medical also depends on the timescale. If it’s a transfer deadline, it’s a short timescale but it will come with caveats. If it’s a full medical, it can take days but will be thorough. 
 

I would love to see this in the game where, if amber or green, the transfer can go through. If red, the club can then give the decision to the manager depending on the confidence level in the manager, the skill of the medical staff, and the amount of time taken for the medical. 
 

Like I said, I would love the communities thoughts on this. 

 

Also, I apologise if this is in the wrong section, this is my first post. 
 

Cheers

 

CL

Rich B
16 years ago
2 hours ago
236
Premium

WHAT AN IDEA!!! I would most certainly use such a mod if it was available.  Any way of making the game more realistic in my eyes is a great idea

buzzfest
13 years ago
3 weeks ago
6
By Rich B 02 January 2023 - 13:03 PM UTC 

WHAT AN IDEA!!! I would most certainly use such a mod if it was available.  Any way of making the game more realistic in my eyes is a great idea

 

Thank you. Any ideas on how to improve/enhance it? 

buzzfest
13 years ago
3 weeks ago
6
By Rich B 02 January 2023 - 13:03 PM UTC 

WHAT AN IDEA!!! I would most certainly use such a mod if it was available.  Any way of making the game more realistic in my eyes is a great idea

I have just had another criteria for the medical process, if stat masking is used in the game, how much of the player is known - the higher the profile of the player/the more known, the better the medical risk assessment, which affects the traffic light system. 

 

Rich B
16 years ago
2 hours ago
236
Premium
By buzzfest 02 January 2023 - 13:09 PM UTC 

Thank you. Any ideas on how to improve/enhance it? 

 

honestly I’d have nooooo clue tbh. But your idea definitely makes sense and much more life like. 
feedback from club doctors and physios should be much more informative when it comes to signing a player. 
perhaps try suggesting it on more sites to get a wider range of feedback. 
all in all mate it’s a top idea and one FM should really look into for future releases. 

buzzfest
13 years ago
3 weeks ago
6
By Rich B 02 January 2023 - 15:19 PM UTC 

honestly I’d have nooooo clue tbh. But your idea definitely makes sense and much more life like. 
feedback from club doctors and physios should be much more informative when it comes to signing a player. 
perhaps try suggesting it on more sites to get a wider range of feedback. 
all in all mate it’s a top idea and one FM should really look into for future releases. 

 

Thanks for your time, Rich, and a Happy New Year to you

weeniehutjr
4 years ago
42 minutes ago
4,950
By buzzfest 02 January 2023 - 12:03 PM UTC 

Hi all,

 

I was wondering what the community thought about an update to the Medical/Physio function in FM about club medicals. 
 

IRL, medicals aren’t pass or fail, they are graded, often on a traffic light system. Green, no problems; amber, some risks; red, some serious risks. 
 

The level of medical also depends on the timescale. If it’s a transfer deadline, it’s a short timescale but it will come with caveats. If it’s a full medical, it can take days but will be thorough. 
 

I would love to see this in the game where, if amber or green, the transfer can go through. If red, the club can then give the decision to the manager depending on the confidence level in the manager, the skill of the medical staff, and the amount of time taken for the medical. 
 

Like I said, I would love the communities thoughts on this. 

 

Also, I apologise if this is in the wrong section, this is my first post. 
 

Cheers

 

CL

 

Nice idea - you should post it here on the official SI forums so they log it as a feature request 🙂 https://community.sigames.com/forums/forum/353-football-manager-feature-requests-pcmac/ 

Rich B
16 years ago
2 hours ago
236
Premium
By buzzfest 02 January 2023 - 15:58 PM UTC 

Thanks for your time, Rich, and a Happy New Year to you

 

Thanks mate and the same to yourself. Really wish you lots of luck with this. It’s something that should definitely be in the game. 

buzzfest
13 years ago
3 weeks ago
6
By weeniehutjr 02 January 2023 - 16:51 PM UTC 

Nice idea - you should post it here on the official SI forums so they log it as a feature request 🙂 https://community.sigames.com/forums/forum/353-football-manager-feature-requests-pcmac/ 

Thank you. I have submitted it now. 

 

You'll need to Login to comment