Hello, everyone!

I'm very happy to announce my final update for FM23. My "Increase Realism"-Megapack OCTOBER Update!

 

Daveincid on Twitter

Daveincid Discord

Daveincid on Youtube

Daveincid on Patreon



READ ME BEFORE INSTALLING
 
  1. Follow me on Twitter and YouTube to stay up to date.
     
  2. If you want early access, ALPHA or BETA access to my updates or even more content, check out Patreon.
     
  3. Delete all my previous files from the “Editor-Data” folder.
     
  4. Make sure you don't use any other files that don't work with my Megapack. This applies to all themes that my mod covers.
     
  5. The Megapack is in most cases compatible with all league files (DaveTheEditor's Around the Globe Megapack is recommended) as well as transfer updates and all possible graphical adjustments.
     
  6. My resources are very limited, so I don't answer questions like "Is your work compatible with X or Y?” - If the general instructions in point 5 are not enough for you, I constantly update a list of files on Patreon which I personally recommend and which will be constantly updated..
     
  7. If you have urgent questions that cannot be answered from the text, please send me a private message here in the forum, on Twitter, Discord or in the official SI-ForumQuestions in the comments will not be answered.
     
  8. The effects of my files in the game are not visible or comprehensible in the pre-editor, so please only give me feedback or bug reports that have arisen directly from the game.
     
  9. I am very grateful for any feedback about found bugs. Especially at this stage (first update) there might be still things which do not work fine yet. However, this must be formulated in such a way that I can do something with it. Please use the template below and send me a PM. I'll read every PM but depending of the issue I might not respond to every message (resource management):

    - Type of bug (visual, game-mechanics):
    - Affected Club/Nation/League:
    - Exact description of the bug + source if any why XY is wrong:
    - Screenshot (if useful):
    - Direct suggestions for improvement based on source XY:
    - Further comments:
     
  10. If you don't want to write me a private message, you can also leave your feedback on the shared Discord server of DaveTheEditor and me.
     
  11. If you need help with the correct installation, you can find it here on YouTube.
     
  12. If you are looking for tips & tricks to make your save game more realistic, you can get some input here in this video.
     
  13. Many thanks to NorsemanLP, who did the graphic design and translation of this post! Follow him on Twitter, he also creates other graphic content for FM23, like the FM.Zweierkette Skin or the Norseman's Logopack!
     
  14. For FM-Fanpages: Write me a private message first, if you want to publish my work on your Fanpage.
     
  15. For File-Creators: All copying of my work (this also includes crediting) is forbidden and I reserve the right to take legal action against it.


"INCREASE REALISM"-MEGAPACK OCTOBER UPDATE

 

  • ALTERNATIVE YOUTH RATING UPDATE
  • YOUTH AND TRAINING FACILITIES IMPROVEMENTS UPDATE
  • WORLDWIDE AWARD FIXES
  • SALARIES MARKET VALUES & SPONSORS UPDATE
  • TRANSFER PREFERENCES UPDATE
  • REALISTIC INJURIES (+ GERMAN VERSION)
  • CLUB DATA FIXES UPDATE
  • CLUB FINANCES FIXES UPDATE
  • CLUB REPUTATION FIX UPDATE
  • TICKET PRICE ADJUSTMENTS UPDATE
  • WORLDWIDE DERBY FIXES
  • LEAGUE REPUTATION CHANGES UPDATE
  • GEOGRAPHICS & LANGUAGES (+ GERMAN VERSION) UPDATE
  • CITIZENSHIP FIX
  • NATIONS AGREEMENTS
  • WEATHER CHANGES
  • NATIONAL TEAM ATTENDANCES
  • NATIONAL TEAM REPUTATION
  • TAXES FIX
  • CLUB TRANSFER PREFERENCES
  • ITALIAN LEAGUE RULE FIXES
  • GERMAN II TEAMS FIX
  • CA/PA CHANGES + NEW WONDERKIDS & OTHERS UPDATE
  • CLUB MORALE ADJUSTMENTS
  • PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENTS FILES 
  • “DaveTheEditor” LEAGUE FILES IMPROVEMENTS
  • STAFF ATTRIBUTE ADJUSTMENTS NEW

 

 

ALTERNATIVE YOUTH RATING

This file changes the"youth ratings", the "game importance"and the"development status" of all Nations. The main purpose of the changes is to provide a more realistic balance of the potential quantity of players after more than 10 years. Nations have different development potential based on over 15 different criteria.
 

 

GENERAL
  • The global distribution of talent was slightly increased.
  • Each nation was individually calculated development potential with over 15 different criteria. For example HDI (Human Development Index), national and international audience average, population, financial resources and many more!

 


YOUTH & TRAINING FACILITIES IMPROVEMENTS

This file improves the balance of the current ability of newgens when they are created. In some cases/nations it was generally too high and in others too weak. The adjustments to the training facilities then ensure that the subsequent development speed is realistic.

 


WORLDWIDE AWARD FIXES

The influence of this file is very important. It improves the reputation behavior especially of younger players. This is too low in the standard game and has a significant positive impact on the age problem (national teams and clubs become too old after 6+ years). There may be some further adjustments in future updates to further improve the age-bug in some Nations. Additionally, it brings a whole new game experience:

 

  • Keeping young players at small clubs becomes more difficult
  • All U-team competitions become more important
  • Reputation behavior has been balanced worldwide
     

 

GENERAL
 
  1. Awards only work in playable leagues, sometimes even only with "full details" (goal of the month etc). So the more leagues you load, the better the reputation behavior of younger players and thus also reduces the age problem in clubs and the national team.
  2. To reduce the age-issue in clubs and national teams in England, France, Italy, Spain, Germany, recommend to load at least 2 leagues as playable in each of those Nations.
  3. Not all awards are real. They are not even in the base game. They primarily serve a function - they represent media hype, interest in certain players, and thus an increased level of fame.

 


SALARIES MARKET VALUES & SPONSORS

Salaries
Salaries are based much more on real data available worldwide. A player from Cameroon no longer earns 500,000 euros, but perhaps 30,000 euros per year.

World-class players earn much more, up to 30-40 million euros gross per year. By default, the end of the line for salaries is in the 20 million euro range.
 

Market values
Market values have been adjusted globally to more realistically represent the effective transfer fees paid in nation XY. The market values in larger nations like England are sometimes way too high. (Many players in the range 100-200€m). This was also lowered. The higher reputation of younger players will boost those values a bit again.

 

IMPORTANT

Some very high "transfer values" are still displayed. These simply tell you that player XY is not for sale. My changes aim to ensure that the transfer fees actually paid are realistic.

Sponsors
The sponsor values have been adjusted worldwide to better balance the finances. In addition, I have calculated individual maximum values for each nation. This is to improve realism, especially in smaller nations, where they grow together with the nation in case of great success. Highly recommended for a "Build a Nation"-save.



TRANSFER PREFERENCES

I have researched all nations on transfermarkt.com which have a preference for players with a certain nationality and adjusted them accordingly. Over 200 nations have been edited!

Not only the nationalities have been adjusted, but also the age preferences. There are certain nations that clearly stand out as "training leagues" based on various data. (Very high percentage of players under the age of 24). For example, Denmark, Austria, Belgium, Switzerland, Croatia or even obscure Nations like Kyrgystan 😉

 


REALISTIC INJURIES (+ GERMAN VERSION)

The injury file has been “reactivated” and should primarily lower the high CA (Current Ability) of older players an boost the rotation, which in turn benefits the young players both in term of CA and their reputation.

There is an extra file in German. Do not use both at the same time.

 


CLUB DATA FIX

This file adds various missing data of over 1500 1st and 2nd league clubs in over 150 nations:
 

  • Club nickname
  • City location
  • Stadium corrections
  • 89 new stadiums
  • Rivalries
  • Foundation dates
  • Club colours


CLUB FINANCES FIX

This file adjusts the financial behavior of some clubs so that even after 20+ years they do not:
 

  • become too rich (except in case of extraordinary success or rich investor)
  • become too poor (except in case of traceable events like mismanagement, relegation etc.)


CLUB REPUTATION FIX

Minor adjustments to improve club reputation behaviour. 

 

 

TICKET-PRICE ADJUSTMENTS

I have adjusted ticket prices in nations where they are calculated incorrectly, which often leads to much too rich teams in certain nations. This mainly affects South America (Bolivia, Colombia, Venezuela etc.) but also other nations like Iran, Iraq. It is unfortunately still not possible to add the correct prices. At least the values are now more realistic and prevent that clubs or whole nations could easily cover their stadium with gold. 

 

 

WORLDWIDE DERBY FIXES

This file adds over 300 missing derbies from clubs and national teams in over 50 nations. It also contains over 1000 reputation adjustments to create a cross-nation balance.


Among others, derbies are included such as:

 

  • "Volga Derby" between Rubin Kazan and Krylia Sovietov.
  • "La guerra del futbol" between El Salvador and Honduras.
  • The "Derby of Ghana" between Asante Kotoko and Accra Hearts of Oak SC and many more


LEAGUE REPUTATION CHANGES

This file slightly reduces the gap between the top leagues and all others in Europe. It also slightly strengthens the top leagues outside Europe and should improve the balance in long term save games.

 


GEOGRAPHICS AND LANGUAGES (+ GERMAN VERSION)

 

Geographics:


The entire world is now covered with real data. From the population of a small village in the Ghanaian desert to the correct altitude of small villages near mountain tops somewhere in Peru. 

 

  • 5500+ Cities edited
  • 1800+ local regions edited
  • Added missing coordinates of 1800+ cities
  • Missing elevation data of 4200+ cities
  • All cities now have a city attraction value

 

These changes may have an impact on:
 

  • The distribution of birthplaces of NewGens
  • Travel costs
  • Sponsor deals
  • Contract negotiations
  • Fitness/injury frequency of the players


I'm sure there are more influences, but I'm not aware of them yet. 😉

 

Languages:

 

  • 100+ new languages created
  • Language difficulty increased by 30% to prevent players from learning the language too fast
  • 181 nations edited in total
  • 1800+ local regions edited
  • adjusted many individual cities
  • and much more!


These changes represent the linguistic diversity of all countries in much more detail. Besides the official languages of a nation, unofficial languages are also included. These are supposed to represent those people who speak a 2nd or even 3rd language without having their 1st or 2nd nationality.


German version:
The German version is in an extra folder. If you want to play with it, delete the English version and replace it with this one.

 

 

CITIZENSHIP FIX

I have made adjustments in 95 nations concerning the years to gain nationality. What sounds easy is quite tricky. The sources are sometimes different and unfortunately in the editor you cannot select the options "Will be naturalised if he has good relations with local politicians" or "Will be naturalised if he invests 1 Million euros in the country". 😉

 


NATIONS AGREEMENTS

This file by "DaveTheEditor" is now included again. It adds 24 agreements between nations. You can find this information in the nation tab overview!

 


WEATHER CHANGES

I have integrated climate change into the game. Specifically, this means that with a small probability (approx. 5%) higher temperatures occur in all regions of the world than those entered by default. For example, in London, temperatures of up to 42 degrees can be reached in rare cases. Previously, the maximum was 32 degrees. This may have an influence on the fitness of the players. So it is definitely worth taking a closer look at the weather forecast for the next match. 😉

 


NATIONAL TEAM ATTENDANCES

All national teams now have the correct attendances added. Unfortunately Football Manager does not implement this 1:1 and the number of spectators in the game is often much higher than it should be. I have taken this into account in my adjustments.  

 


NATIONAL TEAM REPUTATION FIX

For a better game balance I have lowered all national team reputations by 5%.
 

This helps to curb the too strong increase of the league reputation and (not 100% sure yet) encourages the AI to nominate younger players to the national team.

 

 

TAXES FIX

I have adjusted the corporate taxes in Germany and China. These were incomplete in Germany (solidarity surcharge was not taken into account) or incorrectly entered in China.

In both countries, this led to the clubs having to pay far too little tax and thus being in a better financial position than they should have been.

 

 

CLUB TRANSFER PREFERENCES

This works a bit differently in the pre-game editor now, so I needed a bit more time for the file. A total of 39 clubs from 31 nations were edited. In concrete terms, this means that the "club DNA" is now also better recognisable in the game. Clubs that consistently sign U21 players will now also do so in the game. The same applies to clubs that have a strong preference for new signings from a certain nation.

 

 

ITALIAN LEAGUE RULE FIXES

In Italy, the league rules are bugged (even if they are theoretically correct). Clubs in League 2 or 3 often get into financial difficulties. The reason is that they do not meet the stadium requirements for the league. This leads to these clubs eventually building a new stadium, getting heavily into debt and almost choking on it. This actually makes a save game in these leagues unplayable. In reality, the rules are probably interpreted more "generously". I have either weakened these rules or deleted them altogether. This issue was fixed in various nations with the winter patch, unfortunately not in Italy.
 

 

GERMAN II TEAMS FIX

This file is connected with other Files but I decided to separate it. There is an issue in the German 3rd division that after a couple of years the II-teams of big teams dominate the leage (I had up to 12 II-teams in the 3rd league after 10 years). This issue is now massively lower without hardcoding anything.

 

 

CA/PA CHANGES + NEW WONDERKIDS & OTHERS

 

  1. The main focus was to adjust CA/PA values based on players performances in season 22/23, both for performances/debuts in the national league and in international competitions like the U17 european championship or the U20 World Cup. I’ve also adjusted player reputations, missing 2nd nationalities & national team switches.
     
  2. 60+ new talents have been created, some of them Wonderkids. Most of them also have a cut out face pack included.

    In total, more than 7'000 players were adjusted worldwide.

 

IMPORTANT

The values are based on my own research using transfermarkt.com and other platforms. The changes made to the player ratings are not up for discussion, neither via PM nor in any forums, since the in-game implementation is also important and how these players develop over the years. However, if there are any major errors, please report them via PM.

 

 

CLUB MORALE ADJUSTMENTS

I have adjusted the morale of teams in the top 50 competitions worldwide based on their performance/expectation in the 22/23 season. This should result in clubs performing similar to reality.

 

 

PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENTS FILES

I haI managed to optimize 30 default nations (with DaveTheEditor's league files even 62!), so that the day-to-day simulation time is up to 20% faster. There is also a "performance mod players" and a "performance mod clubs ". The average speed advantage in my tests was 12% and the smallest was still 10%. You will also notice a player count drop of about 10% for all setups. This is intended, don't worry, you won't miss those players. They are irrelevant for all default leagues available.

 

 

“DaveTheEditor“ LEAGUE FILES IMPROVEMENTS

Thanks to DaveTheEditor who game me the permission to improve some of his files!
 

Improvements made:

  • There was an issue with the U17 World Cup file by DaveTheEditor that some nations didn’t took part at all. This was fixed by DaveTheEditor and is now included in my update
  • Small improvements for OFC Champions League
  • More realistic academies, especially in african nations. This means that their strenght has been mainly improved and very weak academies has been removed to lower the amount of newgens created in that nation
  • League schedule fix in Turkmenistan

 

 

STAFF ATTRIBUTE ADJUSTMENTS

I reduced the "professionalism" attribute for all HOYD by 2 points. The reason for this is that newgens are on average too professional. With these adjustments I was able to easily counteract this.

 


PLANS FOR FOOTBALL MANAGER 24?

Everything continues in the same rhythm. The first ALPHA for FM24 is scheduled for 10 November! 😉


 

HOW TO INSTALL "Increase Realism Megapack" in FM23

Place all files (not the folder) in "Documents/Sports Interactive/Football Manager 2023/editor data".

 

FURTHER INFORMATIONS INCLUDED IN THE „READ ME“ FILE IN THE DOWNLOAD-LINK
 
NEW SAVEGAME IS REQUIRED!


Have fun! 🙂


Cheers,
Daveincid 


 

Comments
RodyRondaRosey
9 years ago
6 days ago
4

holly shit  thank you brother

Sascha#7486
3 years ago
1 month ago
23

thanks men. :-)

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 “Increase-Realism”-Megapack January ALPHA is now released on Patreon
- 6 new files
- 10 updated files
- League rules fix in Belgium, France, Italy & Spain
- Club transfer preferences
- taxes fix
- Improved player development/reputation behaviour & much more!
Link:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/fm23-increase-16-75992088

 

Cheers
Daveincid

Rochbini Rossi
2 years ago
1 year ago
5

REALISTIC INJURIES (+ GERMAN VERSION)

The injury file has been “reactivated” and should primarily lower the high CA (Current Ability) of older players an boost the rotation, which in turn benefits the young players both in term of CA and their reputation.

 

What are the advantages and disadvantages? and give an example?

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 “Increase-Realism”-Megapack January BETA is now released on Patreon
- 6 new files
- 11 updated files
- League rules fix in Belgium, France, Italy & Spain
- Club transfer preferences
- taxes fix
- improved player development/reputation behaviour & much more!
Link:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/fm23-increase-23-76286116

scotcher1985
15 years ago
1 day ago
5
Premium

Does this slow the game down at all? 

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium
By scotcher1985 29 December 2022 - 23:16 PM UTC 

Does this slow the game down at all? 

 

no

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 “Increase-Realism”-Megapack January Early-Access is now released on Patreon
- 6 new files
- 11 updated files
- League rules fix in Belgium, France, Italy & Spain
- Club transfer preferences
- taxes fix
- improved player development/reputation behaviour & much more!
Link:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/fm23-increase-30-76544313

Cheers
Daveincid

tubuus
10 years ago
3 days ago
40
By Daveincid 30 December 2022 - 18:52 PM UTC 

FM23 “Increase-Realism”-Megapack January Early-Access is now released on Patreon
- 6 new files
- 11 updated files
- League rules fix in Belgium, France, Italy & Spain
- Club transfer preferences
- taxes fix
- improved player development/reputation behaviour & much more!
Link:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/fm23-increase-30-76544313

Cheers
Daveincid

 

Are there plans to fix popular 3D stadiums? For example, Everton.
Using https://sortitoutsi.net/content/61618/stadium-editor-fm-23

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 “Increase-Realism”-Megapack January update is now released
- 11 updated files
- League rules fix in Belgium, France, Italy & Spain
- Club transfer preferences
- taxes fix
- improved player development/reputation behaviour & much more!

Enjoy!

Cheers
Daveincid

BIGJC123
12 years ago
1 week ago
1

Does this mean i cant have the German National team fix?

 

Deleted Account #754931

When are we going to have the Germany NT fix?

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium
By BIGJC123 07 January 2023 - 15:24 PM UTC 

Does this mean i cant have the German National team fix?

 

Why should that be the case? of course you can use the german NT fix

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium
By JRHT 07 January 2023 - 19:45 PM UTC 

When are we going to have the Germany NT fix?

 

Never, because there is already a fix available

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 “Increase Realism”-Megapack February ALPHA is now available on Patreon

- 12 updated files
- New method used to ensure REALISTIC PLAYER DEVELOPMENT - worldwide
- Finances re-balanced - worldwide
- Major AI transfer behaviour improvements & much more!
https://patreon.com/posts/77189627

Cheers
Daveincid

Pchalks
2 years ago
3 months ago
1

Hi. Amazing work 👏 thanks very much! 

 

What is the unzipped file size please? And does it work on the mobile version?  Ta 

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 “Increase Realism”-Megapack February BETA is now available on Patreon

- 12 updated files
- New method used to ensure REALISTIC PLAYER DEVELOPMENT - worldwide
- Finances re-balanced - worldwide
- Major AI transfer behaviour improvements & much more!
https://www.patreon.com/posts/77510038

Cheers
Daveincid

psucolonel
16 years ago
2 weeks ago
22

How do I load this setup once I am in the game?  

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium
By psucolonel 23 January 2023 - 07:20 AM UTC 

How do I load this setup once I am in the game?  

 

HOW TO INSTALL "Increase Realism Megapack" in FM23

Place all files (not the folder) in "Documents/Sports Interactive/Football Manager 2023/editor data".
 

NEW SAVEGAME IS REQUIRED!
psucolonel
16 years ago
2 weeks ago
22

Yes, I put them in the “Editor Data” folder.  Once I am in game, how to I load the custom setup/database?  Is it a pre-made setup, or do I still need to put it all together with the leagues I would like to use?

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium
By psucolonel 23 January 2023 - 07:50 AM UTC 

Yes, I put them in the “Editor Data” folder.  Once I am in game, how to I load the custom setup/database?  Is it a pre-made setup, or do I still need to put it all together with the leagues I would like to use?

 

The files must be activated the same like any other league files

psucolonel
16 years ago
2 weeks ago
22

OK…when using the custom database….I am adding players for “view only” leagues…which boxes should I be checking…when I check them all, it seems there are too many players for the database…..which options will give me the best way to represent players from each nation?  Or should I be using continents or divisions?

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium
By psucolonel 23 January 2023 - 08:07 AM UTC 

OK…when using the custom database….I am adding players for “view only” leagues…which boxes should I be checking…when I check them all, it seems there are too many players for the database…..which options will give me the best way to represent players from each nation?  Or should I be using continents or divisions?

 

This goes onder point 5:
My resources are very limited, so I don't answer questions like "Is your work compatible with X or Y?” - If the general instructions in point 5 are not enough for you, I constantly update a list of files on Patreon which I personally recommend and which will be constantly updated..

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 “Increase Realism”-Megapack February Early-Access is now available on Patreon

- 12 updated files
- New method used to ensure REALISTIC PLAYER DEVELOPMENT - worldwide
- Finances re-balanced - worldwide
- Major AI transfer behaviour improvements & much more!
https://www.patreon.com/posts/fm23-increase-27-77829180

Cheers
Daveincid

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 "Increase Realism Megapack" February update is released

 

What are the key changes?
- Player development in all nations is now realistic. Many nations (especially African and Caribbean) had previously developed far too much and were therefore at a great disadvantage in global competition*
- Development slowed down in other nations (e.g. Thailand, Mexico or Colombia)
- The finances of all nations were balanced with the league files I have tested so far. (Changes will still come in future versions as I will align my files with DaveTheEditor's league files
- The transfer preferences have been adjusted. This became necessary due to the new balance of power and is now delivering an unprecedented degree of reality in the transfer flow.
- As always, many other minor things have been improved

Have fun!
 

Cheers
Daveincid


*In individual cases, the result depends on the selected database. However, it also works relatively well in smaller setups

Horst.Mayer27
1 year ago
1 year ago
1

Does the mod conflict with the fake-lnc?

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium
By Horst.Mayer27 09 February 2023 - 16:29 PM UTC 

Does the mod conflict with the fake-lnc?

 

I've just heard that some fake-lnc may cause the issue that nicknames of clubs won't work. beside that, no.

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 "Increase Realism Megapack" March ALPHA is available on Patreon
- 8 updated files
- 1 new file
- already updated/re-balanced for the ATG v2 by DaveTheEditor (Asia and Africa)
- smarter AI managers & director of football
- II team fix in Germany
- club finances updated
- citizenship fix
- geographics & languages fix
& much more!
 

Link:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/78497751
 

Cheers
Daveincid

espinasse84
4 years ago
1 month ago
1
Premium

Have you added the Juventus points deduction? 

 

Thanks in advance. 

Daveincid
12 years ago
13 hours ago
354
Premium

FM23 "Increase Realism Megapack" March BETA is available on Patreon
- 10 updated files
- 1 new file
- optimized for the ATG v2 by DaveTheEditor (Asia and Africa)
- smarter AI managers & director of football
- II team fix in Germany
- Juves -15 point deduction
- club finances updated
- citizenship fix
- geographics & languages fix
- ticket-price adjustments
& much more!

Link:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/fm23-increase-17-78836313

Other updates:

List of files I recommend for FM23:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/75451581

Custom game setups for FM23:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/fm23-custom-game-74809414

Cheers
Daveincid

You'll need to Login to comment