Joe5p - Comments

Comments
#880040 FM26 3D Stadium Megapack
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

@BassyBoyYT The amount and quality of work is unreal mate. Sorry to go on about Celtic Park again, but is the rail seating section there? The latest video is unreal but it is hard to tell if that section is rail seating/standing from the video. I know it might come in a later version. Can't wait for the pack. The adboards are still back to front along the big stand. Thanks. 

#879435 FM26 3D Stadium Megapack
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By BassyBoyYT 21 April 2026 - 18:59 PM UTC 

To show I'm not just pullin' my pisser, here's a new image😂

 

This is amazing mate, but just a quick observation in that New Balance were the kit maker about five years ago, and I can see their static board. It is adidas that make the Celtic kits, think I shared an adidas board amongst others on the discord. Also, not sure if the case or not, but is that still static boards on the far away touch line instead of the dynamic in front? ‘Intelligent Car leasing’ were an advertisers board you would see at Celtic all the time, but they went bust and can see their board too. ‘Magners' is an easy one to swap in as they are a long term sponsor.  The Tunnel also has very prominent and definite branding this season, with a specific VAR section.

 

There are also no dynamic boards running along the main stand (small one with tunnel and dugout). It is exclusively static on that side, so in the above image, the ones just to the left with the four stewards standing are not there, it is jus static the whole way along that touchline, with dynamic behind the goals and on the far side. 

 

A general view of the newly refurbished Celtic tunnel during a... News  Photo - Getty Images

 

Celtic's Tunnel Vision

NB - Dugouts with dip still shown in the above image, revised below, but the branding of the tunnel with the badge on top and words on side can be seen. 

 

And the dugouts are different to any older models that might be a base from PES, and were raised above ground level, whereby before their was a dip and different seating.  Sharing in the spirit intended, as I know you are really keen to replicate reality. The lighting and general quality is unreal. Thanks.

 

The New Celtic Park Dugouts : ▪️ Raised to pitch level ▪️ 2 rows of modern  seats and a 3rd row of what looks like padded seating (previously there was  only 2
#878565 FM24 League Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

@M.C hope all well. I have had a hiatus from sortitoutsi over the past six months or so but hoping to get back into moderating and the data update in the close season again. Is there any chance at all you could create a Scottish file with the lower league levels for FM24? There are big changes coming this summer below League 2, with the Lowland League splitting into Lowland League East and Lowland League West. It means some of the very large well established lower league clubs like Auchinleck, Cumnock and Pollok are now one step away from League 2. However, the teams going into each league, as well as new teams joining lower levels as a knock on aren't none yet. I can provide all of that when known, just wondering if any appetite to make a file for Scotland that covers lower leagues?

 

Does it seem likely all leagues will again be updated for FM24 given the very mixed feeling on FM26 that still exists? Thanks as always for all of the work you do on the league files with everyone else involved. 

#872879 FM26 3D Stadium Megapack
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By DrFMDoctor 06 March 2026 - 15:13 PM UTC 

@BassyBoyYT 

 

I meant to say Bassy, those Scottish stadiums are among the best detail I've ever seen man! Especially the Hibs, Aberdeen and Hearts.

 

They look like Licensed stadiums from FIFA or PES. Incredible detail mate.

 

How did you manage to get the lighting perfect in them? You can see every incredible little detail of the inner roofs. Not all black like Ibrox etc?

 

 

The Scottish stadiums are amazing, thanks Bassy. Are there plans to revisit Celtic Park and Ibrox given the detail in the newer ones compared to those two? Totally appreciate the list is massive though, thanks again. 

#868578 FM26 3D Stadium Megapack
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Superb update, thanks for all the work, but can confirm as per others, home fans in red, away in light blue in all games. Thanks.

#862227 Data Update Home Thread
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By nigelwestland 01 January 2026 - 20:53 PM UTC 

Love suggesting stuff! One question, when I submitted a new player it says active, but what’s the difference between Active and approved and is there a minimum of information to be added to get it approved? 

Active is the version in the update, approved means the suggestion was approved but was since overwritten by what is now the active version. For detail, as much as possible across all areas is best and gives a greater chance of approval. 

 

#862102 FC’12 Scotland - Premiership 2025-26 [v2.0]
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By einherjer83 31 December 2025 - 22:49 PM UTC 

I just started the championship. But I must ask for a little patience since some of the designs are pretty crazy, and need quite a few hours of work each 😳 league one and two is on our WIP list, but I have no info about any packs until the kitmaker send them. 

 

I am not sure about the updates. I'll check this with the kitmaker @Stefanowls. Personally, I only make the 4th kits, and special kits if only I have free time to spare, as there are only 3 spots for kits in the game, and therefore, 4th, 5th etc kits will have no matter in the game. It's only a “Easter egg”, with no real function. So, imo it's a waste of time to make more than the kits that actually can be placed in the game 😬

Thanks, totally understand, when I referenced an update, it was more the St Mirren 3rd, Dundee Utd 3rd and Dundee 3rd than any fourth kit(s). Appreciate it all takes time and thanks for the work on it all. 

 

#861990 FC’12 Scotland - Premiership 2025-26 [v2.0]
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Hi @einherjer83 , the packs are amazing. Was just wondering if an update to the Scottish Premiership as well as the packs for the Championship, League 1 and League 2 are in the pipeline?

 

Many thanks for all of the work.

#857755 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By bmcc123 23 November 2025 - 00:28 AM UTC 

When downloading the data update, player transfers isn't in it. or am I being stupid lol? (every chance)

Hi, the transfers are contained within this file - ‘sortitoutsi.net FM26 Data Update - Contracts.fmf 

 

Can you see that file?

 

#857754 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By dejong 30 November 2025 - 01:17 AM UTC 

Just a couple of players I found who seem to be duplicates of players already in the FM database- this is for the FM24 update:

 

Nicholas Jonathan (2002044461- Abia Warriors) seems to be the same player as Nicholas Jonathan ( 2000249545- Simoiben)- Similar DOB and CM position.

 

Nikita Zavjalov (2002067559- Akron 2) is probably the same player Nikita Zavjalov (2000152758- FC Izhevsk) - Similar DOB and transfermarkt profile matches original players Football Manager playing history.

Thanks, I think someone may have picked up Nicholas Jonathan as I can only find his profile linked to Abia? If you can find the other profile on here, please send the direct URL. 

 

For Zavjalov, he is an SI games hard coded player twice by the looks of things (as far as I can tell), and is not linked to this update, so we can't remove one, but worth flagging with SI to check if it is a mistake via their official forums. 

 

#857085 Submissions paused due to the release of FM26
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By Footygamer 29 November 2025 - 23:29 PM UTC 

Sorry I didn't check that properly, you're right the free agent is the same player, i've fixed that now with a normal submission and removed the created person from FM26.

 

https://sortitoutsi.test/football-manager-data-update/person/2000398857 

 

I'll look into that other error you got.

 

Thanks, for some reason, I can't see him anywhere on the Lleida page if searching the latest update, and his correct ID is pointing to the created player rather than the DB player if searching for him directly with his UID. I know that link includes the .test, not sure if that matters?

 

Down at 375 checks to go, should get them done by the close of day today. 

#857041 Submissions paused due to the release of FM26
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By Footygamer 29 November 2025 - 22:16 PM UTC 

It looks like someone accidentally linked that Luis Silva from Lleida with this one.

 

I've removed that link now so he will be in future FM26 updates.

Thanks @Footygamer , he is in FM26 already with UID 2000398857, but on a free transfer. I can't seem to get his profile to return anything via our update as it gives an error page but that might be because of the link being removed? It was the correct link, just that SI had him as a free transfer and missed his actual move to Lleida. 

 

I was going to transfer him to Lleida then delete the submitted profile, but with the error message below showing, I can't get in to edit his actual FM26 profile. 

 

Error

  • Url: https://sortitoutsi.net/football-manager-data-update/person/2000398857
  • UTC Date: 2025-11-29 23:06:56
  • User ID: 415141

We are so sorry but it seems our website encountered an error. Please visit the feedback and support forum to report what happened and we'll look to get it fixed straightaway.

 

@sergi_ads for now, he is in the update for FM26. If we can get to his actual FM26 profile, we will transfer him over and then delete the created version to avoid duplicates.

 

Down to 497 players from the FM24 update needing checked against the FM26 database, so nearly there with these issues.

 

#856795 Submissions paused due to the release of FM26
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By sergi_ads 28 November 2025 - 19:17 PM UTC 

Hello, I'm playing FM 24 and I have some questions about the data update:

 

there is a way to include in FM 24 Update new players that are added in the official FM 26 database? for example: #2000502196 Xavi Putxi

 

If I make a new youth player request it will be added only on FM 26 update or it will be added in FM 24 update too?

There are some new youth players that were added on FM 24 update with the submission system that not appear if I browse the data 26 update cause they weren't included in the official  FM 26 database for example Luis Silva is on FM 24 update team Lleida 67148466

 

Thank you for your help

 

Backwards integration into FM24 of players in FM26 is being looked at in the background, and if possible, will happen. But at the moment, you can't create a player that is already in FM26 for the FM24 update. Once we can provide more information on if/when we can include FM26 players in our FM24 update we will. 

 

For Luis Silva of Lleida, I can't find him - can you share a link to his FM24 update profile? Was he at Lleida when added to the FM24 update?

#855814 Submissions paused due to the release of FM26
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By wonbrz 25 November 2025 - 09:49 AM UTC 

I have a few thoughts on the update.

After approving a few "new players," a few players are still missing from the game:

Andy Velásquez

Edwin Tumiri

Alfredo Aliaga

Rafael Corrales

Kevin Olah

Dastan Saptaev continues to play in Kairat, being doubled.




 

 

Thanks, we are aware of Satpaev and a fix will come. For the others, I can see they were added to the FM24 update, but in the background, there is a process whereby we need (on an individual player basis) to check they are not in FM26, or if they are, align their FM26 UID to the FM24 update profile. For context, the list started at around 3500 I think, and is now down at around 750. For those listed above, I will take a look now and try to update so that they feed into the latest update file if not in FM26. For the other 700 or so, we are getting closer to having checked all submitted players from our FM24 update for inclusion in the FM26 update. 

 

Apart from any errors we encounter that require a specific fix, I am hopeful we will have worked through the above process for the remaining 750 players over the weekend. At the moment, the likes of England, France, Spain, Scotland, Greece, Holland etc are complete (bar errors), getting through about 100 a night just now, as were colleagues looking at it in previous weeks. 

 

EDIT - Other than Stapaev, those listed should now feed into the FM26 update at some stage today or tomorrow. There are another 767 FM24 Update ‘New Players’ to go through the checks, but gradually, they will appear if not in FM26 and submitted for FM24. 

#855193 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By Rich Devall 22 November 2025 - 15:30 PM UTC 

I hate to be ‘that guy’ complaining about a free update. But the last couple have been full of errors, multiple players added who were already in the game (Satpaev, Byfield, Subuloye to name a few), now this latest one has 100+ Japanese youngsters who are English for some reason. Then there's the random dude who clearly made himself a -85 at Llandudno, which I kind of respect lol.

Can you help us understand what the issue is with the Japanese/English issue so we can look into it? For the player at Llandudno, what is his name?

 

For repeating players, we are working through those. When trying to keep updates available for FM24 and FM26, anyone created via an update (unofficial like ours) for FM24, that is then officially part of FM26 has to have their new UID linked to their old profile, otherwise the new instance from FM26 and the created version from our FM24 update results in two profiles. It takes a while, but we are getting there. 

 

#850550 Game is broken.
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By Willyfever 07 November 2025 - 14:59 PM UTC 

Is there any feedback thread for FM26 on this forum? I don’t seem to find it.

 

Because it can’t be that the majority on here is satisfied with this mess?

This isn't the official developer website and we don't make the game, this is a fan led site to add to/modify the official game. If you want to let SI games know, then there is a huge thread on their official forum where you can post feedback on FM26 that they will receive. If you post here, there is no guarantee that SI will see it - The thread for SI games on their site is - https://community.sports-interactive.com/forums/topic/594137-official-football-manager-26-feedback-thread/ 

 

#849449 Data Update Home Thread
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By james1987 05 November 2025 - 17:22 PM UTC 

thanks for your answer, ofc I m using history file…so it is normal that the loading time would be hours?

 

It shouldn't be hours, unless your PC/Laptop is very old or limited in terms of CPU/RAM availability. I use the history file, and load around 60 leagues all in, and it can take about 15 minutes to get from the First Screen in FM to ‘Start Game’ (or whichever is the name of the final button when creating a new game), while it processes things at each stage, and then another 15 minutes to load the actual new game. 

#848176 FM24 -26 update
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Do you mean for FM24? Load time is increased simply due to the volume of database changes the game has to action when loading. Everything will work fine provided you don't have any other conflicting editor files, but load time is increased, and often appears to have frozen, but if you leave it, it should work. 

#844459 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By wonbrz 20 October 2025 - 17:35 PM UTC 

Are there any plans to approve new players, skills, and changes? I've been seeing changes not being approved for a few days now.

 

Yes, but the process depends upon volunteer staff availability against work and family commitments, and sometimes the way it works, staff able to look at the data update as their main contribution are all committed to other work, family or personal matters simultaneously. It isn't a conscious decision not to approve, just circumstantial.  For my part, I can start to take a look at submissions later in the week and should get a good run at it then, and I am sure the other staff that do the same (if not more than me) in terms of the data update will be back on it too as soon as they can be. 

#843931 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By wonbrz 12 October 2025 - 20:27 PM UTC 

Has this been fixed and are players added between these dates displayed correctly again?

 

Yes, the most recent daily update and all live updates should now include all players impacted by the above. Thanks

#843817 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

It seems that whatever is going on, if you edit the current live instance and the date stamp changes to today, it is picked up by the next live update. 

#843807 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

@M.C and @Footygamer , I think there is a potential issue here in that it appears a number of ‘active’ and newly created players from around the last week in September up to a date I can't determine are now not in fact pulling through to the update. As well as the player flagged above, I tested a couple from Scotland who both appear to be active but didn't load with all Scottish based players set to load. I will take another look, and tried to edit one there in case it helps. Examples from Scotland were both created around or after the date of the player flagged above.

 

Alfie Archibald at Gretna and Cole Coughlin at Kilmarnock are two examples (albeit I am using Coughlin to test if editing is picked up in the next live update). 

 

I am constantly loading Scottish lower level files with the update and until today, everything has been totally fine. 

 

Edit - Of the players I have added, I can find one active and live in game from the 14th September. Anyone else I have added since was appearing fine, up until today (could have been earlier, as I only re-downloaded today), whereby anyone created after 14th September and up to 8th October is not showing in the latest live update. 

 

#843389 justin lerma
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

I can confirm in the latest update, he is live. If you use the ‘Enhanced Update’ then downloading now should show him at Dortmund. If the daily update, then tomorrow's version will have him there. Either way, you need to delete older update files downloaded from our site, and overwrite them with the new ones. 

 

#843386 justin lerma
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By decio luz 05 October 2025 - 21:17 PM UTC 

OK, good, I know I had it in my save, but in his old club. Did you see if I had any files in the wrong data editor?

 

It looks like you have a few repeating files i.e. older versions and newer versions, but I am not an expert on the various implications. M.C. will be better placed to advise. 

 

At a quick glance, the latest update file you have is from 23rd September though, meaning any updates since then won't apply to new games unless you download again and replace the older version.

#843382 justin lerma
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

I have added him again. There are different issues at play. The search bar is returning players from a previous version of the update, and will likely be sorted out in due course. 

 

There was no Justin Lerma profile active. There were two previous versions, one from November 2024, the other from last week. Both had been rejected at some point, but were likely active prior to that. 

 

He is now back in, and does not need added again. 

 

However, for future transfers, they need to be reverse engineered via the update, in that they need to be assigned to their ‘new’ club and loaned back to the club they currently play for until their actual transfer date. There is no mechanism for future transfers just now, so that work around ensures realistic availability until the actual transfer date (i.e. still able to play for current club, but owned by the new club until the IRL date of transfer, where they will leave their current club and be available for their new club). 

 

He is 100% back in the latest update, and I am in the process of waiting for the 20 minute cycle to let me run a test to verify. 

 

He is at Dortmund, and loaned back to Independiente del Valle. 

 

As for the various editor files, I recognise most but not all, but can't say I have enough knowledge to confirm if he could have been added to any other files that then create conflict. None of Nic33s files would cause the issue, not sure about the others, but @M.C is better placed than me when it comes to editor files and impact. 

 

I will upload a screenshot of his active profile at Dortmund (loaned to Independiente) tonight, which should verify that via our update, he is active and in game. 

#843363 justin lerma
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By elsa micano 05 October 2025 - 14:04 PM UTC 

I did another experiment and now it appears as a central defender with the number 72 and no name. This is all crazy.

 

I can't find an active profile for him within our update, he is not listed at either Independiente or Dortmund. I will quickly check the pending New Player list in case he has not been approved. I am out for an hour or so, but can then re-add him and test via a save. Will be back in touch later tonight. 

#843361 sortitoutsi - unactive players in database
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By tarantulaojedele123 05 October 2025 - 17:30 PM UTC 

Hello, today I was trying to make some changes in IV and V Liga in Poland (especially mazowsze voivodeship), but I realised there are some players (e.g. Michał Markiewicz, Michał Panufnik etc.) who are in database, but they cant be edited and added to their real clubs, because they are not active in the database. Is there any way to idk, revive them, make them active again or something? or I have to create them again? 
If anyone could help me with that, I would be very grateful, as some of the crucial players for these leagues are not active 🙂

Kind regards,
tarantulaojedele123

I have had the same issue in lower levels within Scotland. If unactive, it means SI did not include them at all in the FM24 database (or did at first but removed them before the January 2024 update). From what I understand, you need to create them again. Thanks

 

#843300 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By wonbrz 05 October 2025 - 11:07 AM UTC 

Hi, please remove a player. I duplicated him at the beginning of the year because he's already in the database. I just noticed this now, sorry.

https://sortitoutsi.net/football-manager-data-update/new-person/2100050586

 

Removed, thanks for flagging

#843210 Double Freddie lawrie
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By M.C 04 October 2025 - 17:48 PM UTC 

Thanks @Joe5p - right, that explains the nature of the ‘error’ page that you arrive at when you try to browse (through search) to the one that's now been deleted. It's effectively the same scenario we talked through (I think with @elsa micano, on another thread) about a different player a day or two ago.

 

@elsa micano , I can confirm if you load a game with the latest update the Aston Villa version of Freddie Lawrie is not there, even though he still appears on the site if searched. @M.C , yes, this is part of the wider issue with links just now. Once the duplicate checker is fixed it should be fairly easy to sort it all out. 

#843201 Double Freddie lawrie
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By elsa micano 04 October 2025 - 17:18 PM UTC 

Hi everyone, I found two duplicate players in FM24: Freddie Lawrie, one with ID 2002089134 for Aston Villa, and another ID 2002088428 for Manchester City. I think they're the same player, one is a forward and the other is a defender. Very strange. The one for Manchester City has all the data, the other has no data in the game. Freddie Lawrie 2002089134 and 2002088428 are the same. Go to the search and enter these IDs...

 

Everything MC has said is correct, however, this particular duplicate was picked up a few days ago, and the Aston Villa one was deleted. It still shows in a search here due to a gap between what is held in the update and what is ‘searchable' , but he should not be in the most recent version of the data update, only older ones. 

 

I am loading a save soon this evening and can double check, but when you click on the Aston Villa version returned by a search on this site, you will see the profile has been deleted.