Chera
17 years ago
4 years ago
248
How must Clyne feel? Picked in a squad and then the guy who comes in as a replacement for an injured player starts ahead of you. Would love a journalist to ask Hodgson some of these questions. How can he say he is picking players based on form and then do that. Kick in the teeth to players in the league like Shawcross aswell and others who are in good form but never selected.

Rooney again showing he is massively overrated.....Cue second half hat trick
Crane
14 years ago
4 weeks ago
2,434
Premium
After playing fucking woefully, you just knew he'd score
George14brfc
13 years ago
4 years ago
3,912
ha ha ha get in!
Ninja
15 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
How must Clyne feel? Picked in a squad and then the guy who comes in as a replacement for an injured player starts ahead of you. Would love a journalist to ask Hodgson some of these questions. How can he say he is picking players based on form and then do that. Kick in the teeth to players in the league like Shawcross aswell and others who are in good form but never selected.

Rooney again showing he is massively overrated.....Cue second half hat trick


The media love him for some reason. They won't. I'm not actually sure he's an improvement over McClaren.
Chera
17 years ago
4 years ago
248
That was absolutely woeful.
BR.
18 years ago
2 years ago
1,896
It was pretty grim yeah.

At least the international break is over for now, for about a month anyway.....although the friendly away to Scotland should be alright.
Based Jorge
11 years ago
4 years ago
1,399
Rooney alone cost Wilshere about 6 assists in the last two games.
Slashman X
18 years ago
1 year ago
6,000
Goalkeepers
Fraser Forster, Ben Foster, Joe Hart

Defenders
Leighton Baines, Gary Cahill, Calum Chambers, Nathaniel Clyne, Kieran Gibbs, Phil Jagielka, Luke Shaw, Chris Smalling

Midfielders
Ross Barkley, Michael Carrick, Stewart Downing, Jordan Henderson, Adam Lallana, James Milner, Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain, Raheem Sterling, Andros Townsend, Jack Wilshere, Theo Walcott

Forwards
Rickie Lambert, Wayne Rooney, Daniel Welbeck, Saido Berahino


What the fuck have Carrick, Lambert, Walcott and Townsend done to deserve a callup? Good to see Berahino is there
Poe
18 years ago
2 weeks ago
3,675
Who are better than these players though?

Nathan Dyer is the only player I'd argue that is in good enough form to warrant selection and even then - is he even any good?

Charlie Austin maybe too.

England aren't a team that can afford to pick players on form anymore - you have to pick the best possible players regardless if they're performing for their clubs or not.
Slashman X
18 years ago
1 year ago
6,000
Who are better than these players though?

Nathan Dyer is the only player I'd argue that is in good enough form to warrant selection and even then - is he even any good?

Charlie Austin maybe too.

England aren't a team that can afford to pick players on form anymore - you have to pick the best possible players regardless if they're performing for their clubs or not.


Barry > Carrick, Dyer > Walcott (going by form, Walcott's played about 10 mins in 9 months), Austin > Lambert (offer the same style, Kane might've been useful but not the same 'mould' as Lambert), anyone > Townsend.

Still no Shawcross either, which is a bit shit
Poe
18 years ago
2 weeks ago
3,675
But Walcott is better than Dyer?

Barry and Carrick are non entities in that squad for me - both too old and shouldn't really be playing for England. I'd rather have Barry though, you're right - we don't play with a 4-3-3 and a defensive midfielder though, so that's pointless including him as he's nowhere near mobile enough to play in a 4-4-2.
Slashman X
18 years ago
1 year ago
6,000
But Walcott is better than Dyer?

Barry and Carrick are non entities in that squad for me - both too old and shouldn't really be playing for England. I'd rather have Barry though, you're right - we don't play with a 4-3-3 and a defensive midfielder though, so that's pointless including him as he's nowhere near mobile enough to play in a 4-4-2.


But Walcott hasn't played in 9 months, who knows if he'll even be fit enough. At least have Dyer in there as a backup.

Noble instead of Barry then, or even Cork. Rather than repeatedly trying to shoehorn Wilshere into a DM role
Poe
18 years ago
2 weeks ago
3,675
But these players aren't good enough, the players selected there with the exception of Austin over Lambert are the best players available for England?

England don't play with defensive midfielders ever - it's part of the reason we're so poor. People like Cork will never get a start over Henderson and Wilshere regardless of what they offer.
Slashman X
18 years ago
1 year ago
6,000
But these players aren't good enough, the players selected there with the exception of Austin over Lambert are the best players available for England?

England don't play with defensive midfielders ever - it's part of the reason we're so poor. People like Cork will never get a start over Henderson and Wilshere regardless of what they offer.


At this moment in time, Dyer is better than Walcott and Barry/Noble/Cork are better than Carrick regardless of playing a proper DM or not. You're saying Townsend is a better player than Dyer?
Poe
18 years ago
2 weeks ago
3,675
I'm saying there isn't much difference between them at all.

Walcott is better than Dyer, too. Regardless of how fit he is.
VP.
14 years ago
2 months ago
25,271
On the subject of Walcott he's said he is quicker now than before he was injured.
Shola
16 years ago
6 years ago
2,708
Townsend actually plays well for England in fairness.


Disappointed by the lack of Catts, AJ, Rodders and Wicks though.

And how come Barkley isn't in your list with Walcott and Carrick.
Slashman X
18 years ago
1 year ago
6,000
Honestly didn't see Barkley there, even though he's first on the list
bmg033
10 years ago
1 week ago
2,268
Looking at that squad shows you how low English football is right now. Players that have done nothing this season still make the squad over ones that have. Great work Roy.
Ninja
15 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
Barry > Carrick, Dyer > Walcott (going by form, Walcott's played about 10 mins in 9 months), Austin > Lambert (offer the same style, Kane might've been useful but not the same 'mould' as Lambert), anyone > Townsend.

Still no Shawcross either, which is a bit shit


I really wouldn't be surprised if we signed Shawcross in January and he went straight into the side.
Based Jorge
11 years ago
4 years ago
1,399
I'm happy with Walcott getting game-time tbh. Nailed on starter when fully fit anyways.
.verse
13 years ago
11 months ago
871
England aren't a team that can afford to pick players on form anymore - you have to pick the best possible players regardless if they're performing for their clubs or not.

TBF though, has there ever really been a period of time when England picked players based on form? It's always been the same players picked, irrespective of how they were performing for either club or country. Once upon a time there were those who wanted mainstays like Beckham, Lampard, Gerrard, A.Cole, etc dropped for lesser players who were either in better form or would provide a more balanced system.

These days the pool of quality players England has to select from is dismal, so it definitely makes more sense to base selection on form rather than reputation. Even if it does mean selecting less talented players on occasions.
Telegram Sam
16 years ago
3 months ago
5,082
Premium
In Walcott's case Hodgson pretty much said that he probably won't play (or if he does, it won't be much). If I'm not mistaken after this break the national side won't meet up again for a few months so it makes sense to get him back in amongst the squad given it's the last chance he'll get for a while. He's also one of the best attacking players we have - he's not some shit player on getting in because he plays for a big club.
Shola
16 years ago
6 years ago
2,708
"I don't recall Chris Smalling or Phil Jones ever refusing to play right back."

God, I fucking love Steven Howard at times.
Based Jorge
11 years ago
4 years ago
1,399
Gibbs is likely to play. Good news for England cause he's not a fraud like Baines; bad news is that he'll probably get injured.
Telegram Sam
16 years ago
3 months ago
5,082
Premium
I'm going tomorrow.
bmg033
10 years ago
1 week ago
2,268
Its my birthday today, don't let me down (again) England! For the last 2 years the game nearest to my birthday has ended in a derby defeat. 2012 Spurs lost to Arsenal and 2013 England lost to Germany. Hopefully it doesn't happen again today.
BR.
18 years ago
2 years ago
1,896
Downing playing over Barkley He's had his chance for the last 10 years, just get Barkley in there.

Come on England anyway.
Shola
16 years ago
6 years ago
2,708
So you're suggesting dropping a form player, for a big name?
George14brfc
13 years ago
4 years ago
3,912
Come on England! Hope Grant Hanley has a good game though!

You'll need to Login to comment