I'm not sure it's the right size, because cuts should be either in 180x180 or 250x250. You can easily resize this, naturally.

 

Also, we want cuts to be cropped within 2-3 pixels of the chin, while still having a collar. In cases like this, the collar should be nudged upwards as shown in the tutorial in the opening post.

 

Thirdly, this seems a bit on the small side. One should check the person's timeline, because if they already have a cut which is recent, similar and in 250x250, then a 180x180 cut is unlikely to be considered an improvement, and therefore hardly worth cutting.

@mons Did the image get better?

It's cropped just a little bit less than ideal - you should keep the bottom bit of the facial hair included. It's also missing the collar.

@mons I made this one too.

Better, though now it's slightly cropped too further down.

 

The blue line is where I'd crop it 🙂

 

Selected two pictures of one player, and cutted them.
Not sure which one is better.

 

@mons say you had a picture with a double chin, are we taking it from the lowest one or the highest one? Assuming its the lowest.

I'd prefer the lower one, yeah. Also, in that case, there is a video in the main post on an easy method to remove the green reflecting in his chins.

It'd be good to have the original sources, because it helps us to understand if the eventual cut is actually any good. Also, unless I'm mistaken, I suspect you've used an AI image enlarger.

 

As a rule of thumb, using an AI image enlarger just “guesses” what certain pixels should look like when you make the image larger, and the result looks blurry/out of focus on certain details, with unrealistically smoothened skin, and unnatural looking hair/beard/eye/teeth details.

Fair I just nabbed a bigger guy from the accepted images for this example haha

Here are another set of pictures that I am not sure which one is better.  Both of them is relatively clear, but one of them is from 10 years ago, and another one is with a cap…