Ninja
15 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
What a fucking dick


How dare he join a better club than you for more money to play Champions League football. What an inexplicable move.
Poe
18 years ago
1 week ago
3,675
Kagawa is superb - as is Carrick who can pass as well as anybody.

Man Utd have no real powerhouse in there, in the Yaya Toure mould.
Ninja
15 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
Kagawa is superb - as is Carrick who can pass as well as anybody.

Man Utd have no real powerhouse in there, in the Yaya Toure mould.


Trust me, we're far more desperate for creativity from the deep in 90% of games than we are Fellaini, Yaya Toure or any 'powerhouse'. I'd argue even if we sign Fellaini there's plenty of games I'd much rather see Cleverley alongside Carrick than him. The lack of real creativity and ability to retain possession from deep is the number one reason why we often look so turgid.
Julian.
11 years ago
11 years ago
240
How dare he join a better club than you for more money to play Champions League football. What an inexplicable move.

Join a club that has better players in the same position which would give him limited first team football. And join that club especially after he passed the fucking medical at Spurs.
VP.
14 years ago
2 months ago
25,271
The medical was before any contract talks i believe.
Julian.
11 years ago
11 years ago
240
The contract was agreed verbally
Poe
18 years ago
1 week ago
3,675
Aye but in the big boy world contracts need to be on paper.
Poe
18 years ago
1 week ago
3,675
Trust me, we're far more desperate for creativity from the deep in 90% of games than we are Fellaini, Yaya Toure or any 'powerhouse'. I'd argue even if we sign Fellaini there's plenty of games I'd much rather see Cleverley alongside Carrick than him. The lack of real creativity and ability to retain possession from deep is the number one reason why we often look so turgid.


What's wrong with Carrick and Cleverley for creativity from deep?

I know Cleverley is more advanced than Carrick but surely he's not an attacking midfielder in the traditional sense? Kagawa has that covered anyway.
.verse
13 years ago
11 months ago
871
The only downside to Willians move is that he'll have competition for a regular place. However, Mourinho has always been someone who likes 2 players for every position.

Besides that, he's getting a better salary, joining a better side and will be playing CL football. Outside of that, he's been someone Chelsea have been chasing for the last couple of seasons and tried to sign him prior to his move to Russia. So Spurs can't really complain.

Plus, it's nice to fuck with Levy.
Sam
18 years ago
2 years ago
5,092
He plays off the left for Japan, I'd hardly argue its a completely alien position for him. Regardless, he's not stamped any authority over his position. I agree with you that he'll come good eventually, but so far there's little he's shown to even put him in the same breath as players like that, let alone by justification for not signing them.


I know what you mean about it not really being an alien position for him, but he'd flourish in the center like he did for Dortmund. He was voted Bundesliga Football Player of the Year the season before he came over, playing in his preferred role.

I wouldn't be too pissed off about Willian if I was a Spurs fan, if you get Lamela you'll be fine.
Franck
18 years ago
1 week ago
4,255
Aye but in the big boy world contracts need to be on paper.

Verbal contracts are legally binding pretty much everywhere, telemarketing literally wouldn't exist otherwise.

The difficulty is proving that a contract was agreed to.
Poe
18 years ago
1 week ago
3,675
Verbal contracts are legally binding pretty much everywhere, telemarketing literally wouldn't exist otherwise.

The difficulty is proving that a contract was agreed to.


Employment is usually one that has to be in writing. Especially if it's a contract of employment and not for employment.
Flash.
18 years ago
1 year ago
677
Yeah, you're not going to get away with verbally agreeing on multi-million pound employment contracts.
Franck
18 years ago
1 week ago
4,255
Employment is usually one that has to be in writing. Especially if it's a contract of employment and not for employment.

Alright. That'd make sense.

My post was really just an instinctual reaction to the suggestion that verbal agreements never matter in the "big boy world", when in reality they do matter if they can be proven.

Yeah, you're not going to get away with verbally agreeing on multi-million pound employment contracts.

They do matter if you're making a billion dollar corporate buyout though, as the Texaco oil corporation will attest to.
om4ever
18 years ago
9 years ago
213
What a fucking dick


I'm not over the moon over this move as it a luxury more than a necessity but reaction like that make it worthwile.

I love how Spuds fans went from "with Willian and Lamela were are contenders" to "meh he's overrated and overpriced, we dodged a bullet there" in less than 24 hours
Sam
18 years ago
2 years ago
5,092
Willian having his second medical of the week.

https://sortitoutsi.net/uploads/mirrored_images/f7kBmW5NMOBG2U1Pb6mS8TQxdO2XXrn9dxPn5Z4b.jpg
Ninja
15 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
What's wrong with Carrick and Cleverley for creativity from deep?

I know Cleverley is more advanced than Carrick but surely he's not an attacking midfielder in the traditional sense? Kagawa has that covered anyway.


He's ok, but his positioning is awful, he fades in and out of games and his range of passing is limited. I like him how England use him, but I don't think he's really good enough at enough things to be a really effective player in a two man midfield.
hammer9
16 years ago
6 hours ago
161,681
rumours - Roger Rojas 23 striker from Honduras.... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_Rojas thats i notice his wiki, he joined us for loan.
Jason
18 years ago
6 days ago
4,641
Wiki, always reliable.
bluemoon.
17 years ago
1 month ago
2,411
Premium
I think the only thing it has going for it is that no matter how you look at it there is a perception that Dortmund aren't an absolute top draw team, which Gundogan may share. I remember people saying basically that exact line up until virtually the minute before Götze left for Bayern.

I can't adequately stress how unlikely I think it is (I mean, I don't think we're even trying to sign him regardless of anything else) but I'm never really 100% sure when making predictions about Dortmund.

I understand all that and I can see him leaving in the next couple of years, but there's absolutely no chance he's going anyway this summer.
Ninja
15 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
I understand all that and I can see him leaving in the next couple of years, but there's absolutely no chance he's going anyway this summer.


Yeah, it's hard to see them losing Götze, Lewandoski (effectively) and Gündogen in this window. Especially seeing as they don't need the money.
hammer9
16 years ago
6 hours ago
161,681
Wiki, always reliable.


many rumours from Twitter - He going to medical at upton park tomorrow morning!
Poe
18 years ago
1 week ago
3,675
He's ok, but his positioning is awful, he fades in and out of games and his range of passing is limited. I like him how England use him, but I don't think he's really good enough at enough things to be a really effective player in a two man midfield.


I genuinely think he's one of the best midfielders in the league and I hate Man Utd - I love Michael Carrick.

Apparently Arsenal also want Tim Krul for 10m \o/ Which arm do they want for that?
Sam
18 years ago
2 years ago
5,092

I can't think of anyone else willing to pay that much aside PSG or Monaco?

Bale wants Madrid though so I can't see him going elsewhere. And of course Bale's in Spain for a reason.
Eric Portapotty
15 years ago
1 week ago
3,324
Premium
Really, really odd this, doubt Bale'll change his mind though.
Julian.
11 years ago
11 years ago
240
Bale wants Madrid though so I can't see him going elsewhere. And of course Bale's in Spain for a reason.

For a holiday.
K3V0
16 years ago
1 year ago
5,966
Ah yes because injured players go on holidays when the season starts instead of getting treatment for that injury.
Telegram Sam
16 years ago
3 months ago
5,082
Premium
Perhaps United have offered £60m + Rooney?
tmatthew
18 years ago
1 year ago
771
Nah I doubt there's anyone else interested.
Julian.
11 years ago
11 years ago
240
Probably Arsenal offered £10m + £1.

You'll need to Login to comment