Andrew♣ - Comments

Comments
#315516 Tactical refinement
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
#315423 Really struggling tactically.
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
#315418 2015/16 Barclays Premier League Thread
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
absolutely gutted for leicester, so close yet so far, for me they win that game if not for the red card. still, they have a nice run of fixtures now so it is not over for them, they just need to put todays game out of there minds...
#315330 Tactical refinement
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
#315281 2015/16 Barclays Premier League Thread
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
depay's fm16 stats are looking more and more ridiculous by the day, he has been atrocious this season...
#315230 Players complaining about individual training...
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
Try to train him as ball playing defender because passing is one of the most important abilities of the role.

yes thats what i have started doing now...
#314852 Players complaining about individual training...
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
training isn't rocket science! I only train people in their field or in the area that I want them to play in.

i am well aware that training is not rocket science thanks, i have been setting up training for years in fm and do not have any difficulty in doing so, if you refer back to the original post you will see that this thread is to do with players complaining about my individual training, it wasn't a comment on the difficulty of setting up training...
#314844 What the hell is with the monthly loan fees?
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
Is there something I am missing here.

I want to loan transfer listed Borja Valero.

Fiorentina want 100% of his wages PLUS 240k per month

I don't understand, am I incredibly stupid? Not only do they want me to pay his full wages, thats fine, he will play for me, but they then want me to pay 7 times his wages ONTOP of that, just to have him on loan?

How in gods name does that work out? Not only that, but the 'expected monthly fee' is 400k. 400k for one player.

Lionel Messi's wages, for a 6 month loan

Surely there is something being missed here...by me, or someone else, because not a club in the world would pay 1/2/3/4 hundred thousand a month to loan a player

Help me out? Am I just being really thick, or do they want my entire wage budget for one player?

£240k a month is not seven times his wages so i am not sure how you worked that out, valero earns £134k a month already not including bonuses. ''expected monthly fee'' is the total cost of the loan per month on your wage bill, £400k a month works out at £100k a week, certainly not lionel messi wages. you posted a similar thread previously to do with you trying to get odegaard on loan, i already explained it to you in that thread but you seem to have forgotten about it because you didn't come back with any response. it is frustrating to try to have a conversation with someone who creates a thread and then disappears, if you are going to create a thread then please be prepared to follow through and check it for replies, otherwise you are just wasting other peoples time...
#314322 I give up!!!
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
I've had struggles, and found the best thing to do is really really use your Assistant Manager. On the team selection page, click the shiny new match tactics advice button (near top right on the standard skin), and, assuming your AM has a decent tactics rating, do everything he says. I usually use control at home, counter away, but always what the AM suggests. Then, during the match, always follow AM advice during the game, regarding closing down, changing passing style, tempo. etc. The only time I ignore is when it says "We are being seriously overrun in midfield" because it ALWAYS says that if the opposition has more midfielders than you.

If you're playing as Man Utd, ditch Giggs, he is terrible as 1st team AM. Promote Butt to 1st team AM, and utilise his tactics at all times.

thanks for that advice, i do always sack giggs and bring in a replacement. i have never really used my assistants advice on a match day i admit, i will see if that helps...
#313630 2015/16 Barclays Premier League Thread
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
after next week they have a really nice run of fixtures, i actually think they are going to do it
#313565 Players complaining about individual training...
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
I'm starting to realise there is no point doing anything in FM16, players just whinge about everything possible and even when there is the option to interact they always end up threatening to turn the squad against you! I guess the only way round the individual training is just to let him whinge but leave him doing it, not sure if that will be damaging to his performance levels though.

yeah, at the end of the day the players should do what they are damn well told to do in training. since when do the players tell the manager what to do with training, this is just silly. when guardiola becomes city manager could you imagine the centre backs at city trying to tell guardiola that they don't need to work on there passing
#313561 I give up!!!
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
well at least i am not alone in feeling this way, i am probably going to get sacked as united manager, i will just have to have a hard look at things and see where i can do better. i have never had such a hard time with previous fm games, fm16 has been a nightmare so far...
#313559 I give up!!!
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
I just recently started playing FM 2016 after a 2 year break and I gotta say it's way way harder than it was when I was playing 2011, 2012, 2013... I can see the effects on my players when I change tactics but no matter who I'm playing against there's no difference. They always intercept my attacks and find a way around my defense WAY too easily.

your right, the difficulty really seems to have been cranked up in fm16. even when you have a good tactic that works well it is not enough, the game just wants to screw you over at every turn it seems.
#313503 I give up!!!
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
https://sortitoutsi.net/uploads/mirrored_images/TmrLjWPYiQvfAf7ttP9sFTbVvwXegn3xjOg8P46a.jpg

just look at this shit, how do i lose this, my opponents somehow manage to score 2 goals with 0 clear cut chances, the game hates me i swear there has to be some scripting going on with this game, it cannot be down to luck when this keeps happening all the time...
#313457 I give up!!!
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
just go back to basics. play with no team instructions or player instructions.

what do you do away from home? it seems impossible to get the balance right between attacking and defending, i can set up my defence to be solid but then i end up drawing or losing...
#313366 I give up!!!
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
i feel like chucking the towel in with fm16, its just too hard when it comes to tactics, it feels like you have to get your tactics absolutely spot on perfect every single game just to stand half a chance. even when you feel like you did everything in your power your players will miss an absolute hatful of chances, my team is going through a run at the moment where they just cant put the ball in the net no matter how good the chance is and the ai opponents are lethal with every single chance they get. i just lost having had 25 shots at goal, and my opponents only had 4 shots. absolute bang average players turn into world beaters when they come up against my team, it seems like player quality is almost irrelevant now and its all down to tactics. it seems almost impossible to get results away from home, set up to be defensive and counter and 9 times out of ten its a 0-0 or a 1-0 loss, try to be more attacking and your defence gets wrecked, i don't know what to do anymore.
#313277 Players complaining about individual training...
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
A number of my players are complaining about the individual training i have assigned them to, they say it is not beneficial. For example I am trying to get smalling to improve his passing, but he claims that this is not beneficial, I find this baffling because passing is clearly the weakest area of his game so how can he claim that passing training is not beneficial, this makes no sense. Even more annoying is that there is no option to interact with the player to explain why you have given him that training regime, your only option is to take him off the training or you are stuck with an unhappy player. I didn't have this problem in previous FM games, is there any way around this???
#312392 Transfer Rumours 2015/16
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
what the hell is wrong with west brom, just let him go you muppets, that is a more then generous offer, i don't understand why they are being so stubborn about it...
#312243 Ever lose to a team who didn't shoot the ball at all?
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
i am convinced that sometimes the game just decides not to let you win on a particular day, i find myself many times shouting at my strikers ''how can you miss that you absolute weapon, how many chances do you need''. my other half thinks i am mad, she's always asking me why i keep playing the game when it annoys me so much
#311806 Recalling & Terminating Loan Deals
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
Season long loan deals cannot be recalled unless you are in a transfer window. Also any loan where the team has paid a fee upfront prevents you from recalling the player.

thanks for repeating what i already said in the post directly above yours...
#311474 Reached a dead-end
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
Alright guys,

I'm in limbo over what to do in my future FM career. I've just finished the end of the 3rd season with Blackburn Rovers.

1st season - Playoff semi - Lost
2nd season - won league & promoted to premiership
3rd season - relegated - finished 19th,back down to Championship.

It's summer, & i applied for the Uruguay job and got it, i'm just currently in the group stages of world cup and have won 2 out of 2. My reputation is average and probably what is expected for a Blackburn Rovers manager. I feel like i don't want to manage in the championship and don't know whether to resign or just stick it out for a while longer & see what i can do in the future?

My bank balance is healthy at £40m & a few stars such as Ravel Morrison will fetch me £8/£9m yet too..

LIMBO!!

if i were you i would stay with blackburn and try to establish them in the premier league, you have a very nice transfer budget to work with so you should be able to bring in some good players that can compete at prem level, learn from the mistakes you made the season you got relegated...
#311342 Player Interaction - Actively Seek Transfer
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
We've all been there. Player is unhappy, and wants to leave. Offer him for transfer for silly money, and no offers.

Then you see the box - Ask <player> to speak to clubs.

Click it, and have a player interaction telling the player to look for a new club.

Only

has it ever actually worked? I've never said that to a player, and they've come back and said they've found a new club, or a club has made an offer based on the player or agent contacting them.

So why is it in the game? What's the point?

i agree with you, it doesn't seem to do anything, i have used it many times and not once has an offer from another club been forthcoming, i just have to keep lowering the price until clubs make an offer. i suppose the idea is that the players agent will go to different clubs offering him around, but if i have already offered him out to clubs myself then what difference is that going to make, its an odd one for sure...
#310824 Parent Club
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
RB Salzburg have great resources and as such should generate a healthy youth team. plus they must have some disgruntled second stringers you can take advantage of. I would be happy with them as a parent club as a lower team.

but he can't get promoted, he's stuck in the lower league...
#310475 Parent Club
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
for all intents and purposes fc liefering are red bull's b team, just like barcelona have a b team that are not allowed to play in the same division, so no, there is nothing you can do about that unless you use the editor. you can remove the ''cannot play in the same division'' clause by using the editor i believe, that is your only option i think.
#310460 2015/16 Barclays Premier League Thread
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
disgraceful performance, thats as bad as we have been all season, looked like we didn't want to win the game and were happy to take a 0-0...
#310034 Ball Winning Midfielder
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
So I typically play a standard 4-4-2 with my teams, especially lower league, simple and easy to understand. I usually go with a ball winning midfielder role (on defend) and a centre midfielder role (on support) as my middle two.

My issue is that I find the ball winning midfielder picks up a huge (and I mean huge) amount of yellow cards throughout a season, and is sent off quite frequently! It's the only position in the team that seems to collect cards for fun, whichever player I put in there. On my current save, I've had my 1st choice in the role pick up 16 bookings and 3 red cards, which has totalled roughly 11 games suspended for him!

The other lads I put in there also tend to reach at least 10 yellows a season.

Anyone else have this issue and what have you done to reduce the cards? Or is there a simple way I can try to reduce the number of cards (whilst still keeping the role as Ball Winning Midfielder)? The player instruction doesn't allow me to change the tackling instruction.

why would you want to change the tackling instruction, if you did that he wouldn't be a ball winning midfielder anymore, if its not working for you then pick another role, theres plenty to choose from. one thing to take into account is the tackling attribute of the player, you want as high a tackling attribute as possible for a ball winning midfielder, if you have a player with low tackling attribute in that role he is more likely to mistime tackles and commit fouls, and that means more cards. this is more likely to happen in lower leagues when you have players with much lower attributes, so you should perhaps not use that role in lower leagues.
#309219 Manchester United Career Mode; Academy to Champions League
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
hey stephen, don't i recognise you from full time devils, i am a long time follower of that channel. nice to see you on this forum dude, good luck with the playthrough
#309212 Your Tactical Style
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
Do you find that makes a big difference ??? If so I might have to give it a go

i retrain players to new positions all the time, in my southamption save i retrained wanyama to be a centre back instead, i looked at his attributes and decided he would be much better suited to that role...
#309209 Defenders & Closing Down
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
#309200 Non Foreign Database (WIP)
Andrew♣
16 years ago
3 years ago
238
I haven't played yet only holidayed and took over a few big clubs to see what their expectations are so not sure. I think they would take into account that they have a transfer ban

ok thanks mate, i am definitely going to give this a go as it looks like a very interesting challenge, thanks for the work you have put into creating this database...