Joe5p - Comments

Comments
#831862 FM24 Club Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Not sure if this is the correct place to flag Extinct clubs, but a few in the SI database are now extinct and others have returned to formal pyramid leagues in Scotland. Came across these as I was adding lower league player updates all the way down the pyramid. 

 

Loch Ness (Now Extinct)

Peebles Rovers (Season in Abeyance from all football - only announced this week, effectively extinct for game purposes in terms of a 2025/26 update albeit abeyance leaves the door open to return next season)

Broomhill (Now Extinct, as of this summer)

Upper Annandale (Now playing in amateur leagues, so not technically extinct, but are now outwith the Scottish Pyramid structure as they have withdrawn from the South of Scotland league due to compliance issues)

 

For all of the above, I have moved all players to their new clubs or released players given the clubs are not functioning. 

 

There are two reinstated Clubs that are shown as extinct in the game database (can add players via update but adding to what are regarded as extinct clubs)

 

Inverness Thistle (are in the database as extinct, reformed, now back in lower leagues for 2025/26)

Hall Russell United (are in the database as extinct, have been active throughout 24/25 and still active in 25/26, but were previously in abeyance when SI released the last game)

 

New Clubs in the Scottish pyramid (thanks MC for adding to the Scottish file)

 

EKYM

Cowdenbeath Central

#831817 💡 Alternative Metallic Logo Request Thread (closed)
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By bakizp 17 June 2025 - 20:26 PM UTC 

Here you go, I'm leaving here the cut source so you can submit it when club gets ID eventually.

 

 

Thanks for this and the others mate, much appreciated. However, a few weeks after forming, they have changed their badge! This is the new one. Thank you. 

 

#831808 💡 Alternative Metallic Logo Request Thread (closed)
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Hi, would it be okay to make this logo? Many thanks as always. 

#827775 Scottish Fantasy Pyramid System
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Data Update for Scotland (players, will get back to managers at some point) should be up to date as of today (against all publicly available information I could find), for Lowland, WoS Premier, 1, 2, 3, 4 and EOS Premier.

 

Highland should be easy to source when I get to it. Other leagues less so, but going to trawl all social media for all clubs once, then again once the window closes, and update as and when things crop up.

 

Loads of other contributors too at League 2 and above, but for now, Scottish data update is pretty accurate for a large number of leagues and clubs. 

 

Main issue as always is that a lot of players are not in the database, even if I know which club they have joined or left.

#827579 FM24 "Database could not be loaded" error appears inconsistently
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Sometimes this occurs when your disk space is running low, had same problem, and when I checked C drive capacity at load times, it triggered if very low. Problem I had was too many email pst or ost files saved via Outlook on desktop. Once I sorted that, no issues, but same error and due to disk space. 

#827131 💡 Alternative Metallic Logo Request Thread (closed)
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Hi, 

 

Thanks for EKYM, think this is the last of new Scottish pyramid sides, Inverness Thistle (different to Inverness Caledonian Thistle) have also now joined the lower levels of the pyramid. This is the only version I can find, sorry it has a background. Would it be okay to create this one too? Many thanks as always.

 

#826275 💡 Alternative Metallic Logo Request Thread (closed)
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Thanks for the Cowdenbeath Central logo, much appreciated. Today, one other team was added to a lower league in Scotland. Again, they should make FM26, and when they do I will upload the files to the main pack submission, but would it be okay to create a metallic logo for EKYM FC? Thanks

 

#825457 💡 Alternative Metallic Logo Request Thread (closed)
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Hi, there is a new club joining the Scottish lower leagues, but they are not in the SI database for FM23, so I can't allocate to a source via the normal forum. Would it be possible to create a metallic version of this badge? 

 

Once FM26 comes out I will upload the created file to the normal forum when the ID is known. 

 

Thanks.

#825456 KDM Evolution Trophy
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

New Competition Name/Sponsor for season 2025/26, hence new logo. https://spfl.co.uk/league/challenge-cup 

#821645 Stadium banners
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

The issues a few years ago with sharing banner packs killed a lot of this off in terms of distribution. strangerthankindness and rabcp were both great at sorting it all out at the time. I use AI these days to quickly generate banners. Still working to get any AI to create video for dynamic boards. AI might be your best best for Al-Hilal. 

#820799 Scottish Fantasy Pyramid System
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Hi William, 

 

Hopefully SI fix it, but in case they don't for any future files, noticed the CAS Elite U18 league in game has the incorrect number of teams. Game file has 9, real life has 11. Killie and QP are missing in the game and are in the second tier. 

 

In real life, the second tier has nine rather than eleven with the 9 being those other than Killie and QP. 

 

I think it is a legacy issue as Killie and QP went ‘elite’ at U18 about two and a half years ago, so it could be that was when SI locked the data down. 

 

The ‘Advanced Youth’ Third tier is also incorrect, in that Edinburgh City and Bonnyrigg Rose U18 play in that league, but Stirling Albion don't anymore, and there are eight teams rather than the seven in game. 

#820598 Shay Kelly
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By mons 17 April 2025 - 14:11 PM UTC 

@Joe5p, when you have a lot of images to upload, then you should upload them as a pack instead of individually and save the both of us some time.

You can also upload up to 50 images per pack instead of just a maximum of 5 when done individually. 

 

Thanks mons, I only had six and from memory, haven't uploaded before today, but will know for next time, will get the other one uploaded on its own and then any others I'll stick in a pack moving forward.

 

Apologies for any time wasted, I have eight kids and a busy job, so I know well the frustration with lost time.

 

Cheers

 

#820582 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
#820463 Chris Erskine
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By Footygamer 31 March 2025 - 17:02 PM UTC 

@Joe5p  Can you describe the things you've attempted when describing things like this so it's easier to see any issues and don't duplicate the same efforts.

 

The first step is always to click “Download” to download the XML and then use the PGE > Import function.

 

From there I can quickly see that it's giving a “Record Not Found” error

A search for Chris Eskine shows no results:

Reloading the database using the original 24.0 database instead does show a result so it seems like he was in the original DB but not the updated one, which is why he isn't updating.

 

He would have to be readded as a new player using the “Add New Player” button on the Glenafton page.

 

I could maybe come up with some tool to automatically recreate people that SI deleted, there are a few wonderkids that have had it happened to as well. But also, it's not so many that creating then manually should be okay

 

Thanks for this @Footygamer , and apologies for the scarce information. I added him via the Glenafton page, and also added one more older prominent player at Cowdenbeath, but both were rejected via the New Player Submission moderators. There is also a Kyrzygh player I had tried to flag at Clachnacuddin that doesn't play for Clachnacuddin but someone has created him as new and he is still active. I am not sure who is leading on moderating new players, or I would reach out to them about all three. Thanks for getting back to me when so busy. 

#820014 Scottish Fantasy Pyramid System
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By Davke1904 11 April 2025 - 23:53 PM UTC 

Hi mate, which skin is this please? 

 

OPZ Elite Blackout mate, it is a good skin. Not sure if on sortitoutsi but it is out there somewhere on the sites. Badges are the metallic pack from this site. 

 

As an aside, I have been working away at the data side, had about forty clubs reply directly in past two weeks to try get squads accurate for end of season. Still a few leagues to go but some teams significantly updated. Odd, as the main database has really good coverage of some leagues (North Caley for example), and really poor of other leagues (WoS for example). 

#819637 FM24 Player and Staff Updates
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Hi everyone, 

 

Clachnacuddin in the Scottish HIghland league has an incorrect player added via the new player file. 

 

https://sortitoutsi.net/football-manager-data-update/team/5201713 

 

His name is Adil Mukhtarkulov but he has never played in Scotland, and as per his transfermarkt profile plays for a team from his homeland, but that team is not in the database. Thought to flag for deletion. 

 

https://www.transfermarkt.com/adil-mukhtarkulov/profil/spieler/1190682 

 

Thanks

#818656 Chris Erskine
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Hi @Footygamer , still having no joy with this player, no matter what it seems to have him stuck as a non-player. I know you will have loads on but thought to flag again in case there is a fix. Thanks

#818560 3D Cutscene podiums for ukrainian tournaments
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By dekor144 29 March 2025 - 19:03 PM UTC 

Thanks for your comment🤝, great news for you because the FM23 pack works for FM24

 

Thanks mate, unfortunately, it doesn't have Scotland, and even though licensed, for some reason, it doesn't seem to work in my save. I should have been more specific, it is the Scottish ones I am looking for. I might have deleted the ones that come with the game for Scotland though, so it could be my fault, or maybe the Scottish ones with FM24 are just really basic this season.

#818542 3D Cutscene podiums for ukrainian tournaments
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Amazing work, thank you.  I wasn't sure if this was still possible. There was a great pack for FM21 or FM22, but not sure one exists for FM24.

 

Would be amazing if a similar pack was out there for FM24.

#817902 Scottish Fantasy Pyramid System
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204
By William nicol 21 March 2025 - 12:59 PM UTC 

Thanks for letting me know never seen anything like that in any saves had celtic and hearts b in for 3 years like real live but mite have to change it to even 1 season so this does not happen.

 

I think it is probably because I was Celtic and just simmed, so maybe the fact I wasn't doing anything but neither was the AI it led to them losing almost every game one season. It doesn't seem to have caused any issues yet though, and three seasons is better than one! I will let that SIM for a good bit and let you know if any issues crop up. 

 

Thanks again for the file, it is amazing

#817844 Scottish Fantasy Pyramid System
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Hi William, 

 

Not sure if it matters much in the sense it hasn't caused a crash, but I noticed when simming a career after various graphic updates and installing the latest data update, that Celtic B have ended up relegated via the Lowland League and still competing in 2027 in the WoS Premier. Hearts B seem to have ceased playing in the Lowland League in line with current expiry of that arrangement. Just thought to let you know, as don't know if the rule can exist that would mean neither B team could be relegated in the same way they can't be promoted? I guess that on the rare occasion this happens they are then stuck in the lower leagues forever rather than only being able to play in the Lowland?

 

Not sure there would be any potential longer term issue if other teams kept getting relegated into the WoS (in terms of max team allocation for those leagues).

 

Thanks

 

#810752 FC'12 Scotland - Championship 2024-25 [v2.0]
#810142 Scotland - Scottish Premiership 3D'24/25 New! (01/02/25)
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Thanks for these. Do you know if the missing kits will be added? No problem at all if not, but thought to check in case. The missing kits are:

 

Aberdeen third

Celtic third

Dundee Utd third

Hearts third

Hibs third

Kilmarnock third

Motherwell third

Rangers third

St Johnstone third

 

Ross County, Dundee and St Mirren only have two kits, so none of theirs are missing. 


Thanks again

#807682 Shaun Cameron
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

This player is in the original database twice, other profile already also correctly at this club. 100% same player.

#807668 Omar Marmoush
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Please submit once confirmed by official club sources. While journalists and media are usually right when it gets to this stage, the update can only be confirmed once one of the clubs involved confirms. 

#807576 FC'12 Scotland - Championship 2024-25 [v2.0]
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Hamilton Accies wore a new third kit last night, no sponsor, best image on their official feeds is the back, but same as front other than the badge.

 

Thanks

 

 

#807052 Scottish Fantasy Pyramid System
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Squads, where possible, for EOS2, EOS3 and Midland updated. Just North Caley, North Premier and North Championship to go. Will then backtrack to try to capture any deals missed since I started the bigger update on the 20th December, then try to maintain at least until the window shuts.

#806927 Mathias Fjørtoft Løvik
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Deal not confirmed yet, can resubmit once confirmed officially by either club. Thanks

#806735 Scottish Fantasy Pyramid System
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

Data update wise, to complement this brilliant file:

 

Lowland, Highland, WOS Premier, WOS1, WOS2, WOS3, WOS4, EOS Premier, EOS 1 and SOS all updated as much as I can source. 

 

I hope the much maligned new SFA comet system is public facing, as Scotland really needs a central searchable source for players. Some clubs have great data and social media, some horrendous. 

 

Found about 200 players that were in FM23 or earlier but are not in FM24 which is a shame. 

 

SOS is a shift, lots of clubs with very young local players nowhere near the database and some crazy scorelines when you start looking across the data. Would be aswell joining the WOS, and any team not willing would then be as well to join an amateur league. 

 

Will keep going, hope to finish EOS2 and EOS3 before the week is out. 

#806530 Chris Erskine
Joe5p
13 years ago
1 day ago
6,204

@Footygamer, hoping for some help with this one. He is a player, a high profile one at this level. Changed details, but he won't load in game at all. Is there anything I need to do? Thanks