Home
Blog
Careers
Forums
Downloads
FM24 Real Name Fix
FM23 Real Name Fix
FM23 New Leagues
FM24 Tactics
FM24 Data Update
FM Database
FM Guides
FM Shortlists
FM24 Wonderkids
FM24 Free Players
FM24 Bargains
FM24 Players to avoid
FM24 Club Budgets
FM24 Club Facilities
Graphics
Installation Guides
Records
Prediction League
Fantasy Football
Search
Jason
Felt we could have won the game has Sammon not been rugby tackled at the end
Wasn't expecting that amount of Newcastle fans to come up! I think Cisse found out Basham is a Sunderland fan half way through the game or something
Poe
I don't normally take notice of friendlies, tbf.
Our defending has been shambolic throughout though.
Grimnir
Poe
Has been shit for about a year tbf but I don't think many would look good playing next to what is effectively a lamppost with hair.
Shola
I also love the not boring not 'Premier League quality' moniker. Newcastle conceded about 7 goals all season in the Championship with Kadar, Hall and super Zube.
Number 1
With any luck Mbemba will be decent but a CB with Prem experience could be useful. I also think we need a left-back, but who knows. Apparently Charlie Austin is close too.
Meanwhile John Carver has said he wants to manage NUFC again. Dear God haven't we suffered enough: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/teams/newcastle-united/11766550/Ex-Newcastle-head-coach-John-Carver-I-took-a-battering-for-being-honest.html
Poe
Taylor is just about a Premier league quality defender.
Who knows what Lascelles and mbemba are like.
Coloccini doesn't want to be here.
Yet were going to waste 15m on another striker when we already have 3 good ones and not improve the defence at all. Baffles me. All this attacking prowess and were still going to be dog shit at the back.
Number 1
I'm also slightly alarmed that Gael Bigirimana has been designated back-up to Daryl Janmaat, given Bigi has played there in 3 of the pre-season games so far. Much as I'm not convinced by our left-back options as well, we're tempting fate by only having one senior RB (Steven Taylor may've played there before but hasn't done in years).
Meanwhile, Adam Armstrong is joining Coventry City on loan. I do think he needs some time out at a lower league side so that could be beneficial.
In terms of defensive targets, I did like the look of James Chester, but the word from Sky is that West Brom have agreed an £8million deal. Bit of a rip-off that.
Poe
8m for a bang average defender is way too much.
Means we can sell Williamson and move on to maybe buying a winger too.
If we only sign Mbemba in defence I'll be extremely disappointed.
Number 1
Poe
Fingers crossed we don't ruin the good work we've already done.
Flash.
You really need someone with a bit of experience of England to come in.
Poe
Shola
Yeah. That't precisely the problem.
Also Williamson 'hoofs it long' - Do people honestly think that it's his fault? That's clealy the fault of the midfield for chronically underperforming. It's the midfields job to take the ball of the defence ffs.
Williamson isn't PL quality? Did you not watch Newcastle in the championship? He was miles better than all of the opposition.
Good to know Veltman and Van Dijk are guaranteed hits, whereas Mbemba isn't? Van Dijk must have really impressed you in Celtic's CL defeats at the hands of Legia and Maribor.
bmg033
Williamson is top end of the Championship quality. Possibly good enough for a newly promoted team in PL at best.
Number 1
Even when we had a midfield worth passing too, he would be likelier to play it long. But the issue is less that, and more the fact he seems gone like the rest of our defence seems to have. In 2011/12 and the first half of 2013/14, he put in some impressive performances, and I don't really quite know what the fuck has happened aside. We've conceded 190 league goals in three seasons, and as a unit, something has gone extremely wrong. Maybe its easy to blame certain players, but Krul, Colo, Willo, Steven Taylor and Haidara have been around for most of that period, as had the old coaching staff.
Had this been a year ago, I'd have said yes. Two successive relegations doesn't half feel like its tempting fate.
Poe
Well why does Collocini not have the same passing success rate as Williamson?
He's top half championship quality yeah, not Premier League though.
Chera
Shola
Williamson's passing % isn't exactly bad. It's somewhere in the middle. Even though its a pretty meaningless stat.
The reason Newcastle concede far too many goals, is because the team are far too prone to just stop playing when it gets tough. turning 1-0 defeats into 3 and 4-0 defeats a lot. How many times do Newcastle get players sent off when they're losing for some stupid reason?
Anyway, I don't think I've seen anyone ever sign for Newcastle who has a better write up than Mbemba. Which pretty much guarantees he will be shite.
Poe
Mbemba has came on to play right back though.
The next mbiwa?
Shola
Poe
Had so much promise too, so much for top 8
Shola
Poe
It needs far more than 30m on 3 players.
We need another 3 minimum for top 8.
Shola
Last season's top 7,8 and 9 look to have gone backwards. If we're not up there next season. Then chances are someone has done badly.
And regarding Williamson - he will probably start as Newcastle's 4th choice CB.
Our 'rivals' 4th choice CB - Muniesa, Gardos, Bartley, Yoshida, Collins, Olsson, Wasileske, Delaney, Senderos, N/A.
The N/A is Everton as they've only got 2 first team CB's as of now.
Number 1
Be interesting to see if we can develop him into a future first teamer.
Jason
Surprised you've not let him stay at Northampton for the season on loan, don't see him getting into you starting 11 anytime soon.
Number 1
Presumably he'll be loaned out to a League One side at some point like Adam Armstrong has been.
Poe
Happy that Coloccini has signed a new deal too, hopefully it'll mean the performances of the last 2 seasons will perk up now there's less uncertainty about his future.
He was outstanding in the season we finished 5th.
Shola
Maybe Pardew was right?