Marvin Zeegelaar - Submissions - Cut-Out Player Faces Megapack

37005651

Timeline

mons
18 years ago
3 hours ago
91,483
It's debatable whether this would be an improvement

As posted elsewhere for a similar reason, the current megapack image was only created a couple of months or so ago and it's cut from a high-quality source. While your source is good (and I wish all players had source images as good and easy to cut), I just don't see the point in having a slightly different cut to the existing megapack version and I would much rather see cutters spending time on genuine improvements and missing images.

Apart from the source quality, you should also keep in mind the existing megapack image when making a request. Just because it's a newer image doesn't necessarily mean it's an improvement. I'm not rejecting it, but I doubt whether I'd consider any resulting cut for inclusion into the MP. Just letting you know so you keep it in mind for any future requests
Baja
14 years ago
13 hours ago
35,851
Already done somewhere at site,but not considered as improvement.Also,this is not even best available source.
Sir William
14 years ago
2 years ago
142
Already done somewhere at site,but not considered as improvement.Also,this is not even best available source.


Sorry about that, you wouldn't know where I could find it would you?
Baja
14 years ago
13 hours ago
35,851
I'm looking for him right now,if I found him,I'll send you
mons
18 years ago
3 hours ago
91,483
@BajaHater and @Sir William, Here it is

For future reference, you can search whether the same player (and the same source) have already been requested by using the section outlined in the attached screenshot.

Baja
14 years ago
13 hours ago
35,851
@BajaHater and @Sir William, Here it is

For future reference, you can search whether the same player (and the same source) have already been requested by using the section outlined in the attached screenshot.

My opinion is clear,current one is better as you know @mons Main reason is because original source is done from HQ source
Sir William
14 years ago
2 years ago
142
It's debatable whether this would be an improvement

As posted elsewhere for a similar reason, the current megapack image was only created a couple of months or so ago and it's cut from a high-quality source. While your source is good (and I wish all players had source images as good and easy to cut), I just don't see the point in having a slightly different cut to the existing megapack version and I would much rather see cutters spending time on genuine improvements and missing images.

Apart from the source quality, you should also keep in mind the existing megapack image when making a request. Just because it's a newer image doesn't necessarily mean it's an improvement. I'm not rejecting it, but I doubt whether I'd consider any resulting cut for inclusion into the MP. Just letting you know so you keep it in mind for any future requests


Thanks mons and I will take everything you said into consideration
mons
18 years ago
3 hours ago
91,483
My opinion is clear,current one is better as you know @mons Main reason is because original source is done from HQ source

I agree with you 100% and the present image will remain in the megapack until a better one comes along. However, I forwarded a link to the other request in case @Sir William wants to use it in his game, which he is perfectly entitled to do, and also to notify him how he can use the search function to see if the same request was recently done
1364x2048
This image is part of a pack: Udinese
Pending by Side Splitting Pass on 05 Jan 2021 18:29:13
In Progress by alex164 on 06 Jan 2021 04:39:09
Completed by mons on 07 Jan 2021 13:33:23
250x250
This image is part of a pack: Udinese
Pending by alex164 on 06 Jan 2021 04:40:20
Completed by mons on 06 Jan 2021 07:56:26
250x250
This image is part of a pack: Udinese
Pending by HRiddick on 15 May 2021 08:49:36
Completed by mons on 15 May 2021 09:08:24
250x250
This image is part of a pack: Udinese Calcio 2021/22
Pending by DarkNaples on 12 Nov 2021 23:40:52
Completed by mons on 13 Nov 2021 08:29:41