Kaftan - Comments

Hey everyone It's me again... I'm curious how player role can affect liquidity of the team.

First Scenario: Imagine that your team is full of SINGLE Position players. Central Midfielder is Central midfielder only, Left winger is left winger only etc. Having 11 players who can play only at one position, and then you are pressing the button to engage all players in fully liquid team - to switch positions in fly.
Would that cost you? what about a performance, results etc.

Second scenario: Lets create a ultimate team - team who has 10 players who can play at every possible role expect goalkeeper, from libero to forward from right to left. and You do the same - play as a liquid.

Third scenario: Well its in the middle of those two. Let's say that every defender player can play on every defense role, midfielders could play at every midfield role, and same with forwards. Again you force your team to exchange positions on the fly.

PLEASE NOTE:
We are talking about imaginary team - to avoid meaningless talking about positioning lets say that EVERY PLAYER STAT is set to 20 expect injury proneness, dirtiness, and controversy. Roles are also set to 20, Formation knowledge ( every single stats when it comes to formation) is also set to max.

Which one of the team would You choose, which one would have the best "match performance"
Share your opinion

I'm not sure my self what went wrong... last season i had no issues (18 players went on loan for the 1st squad to clubs around the world)

I'm offering them for free ( no monthly payment and salaries set to 0% time - end season ) no forced positions or additional aspects ...

As history you mean history of the clubs, where Ronaldo played? History of his accomplishments like Golden Ball and other awards or History of his goals, injures red/yellow cards?

Anyway as far as i know, I don't know much ... while duplicating player you are creating new ID, that means a completely new character appears with same name and stats as Ronaldo. New ID also means that player never existed in history of this or another club.

So copying History of Ronaldo to duplicated player is impossible
This is just my opinion

OK so my team got many wonderkids/teens. How do I know? I'm using FMGenieScout and FMRTE

I got unusual problem with loaning players - Since i do not have more space in my main squad to squeeze more kids into first team i decided to loan those future superstars. Their value for now is over 10KK euro each at age 18/19 and here comes problems. Only famous clubs like BVB Villarreal propose their offers most of them is a backup or squad rotation. Instead that i prefer to loan a player to a smaller club but for better treatment im expecting first team proposal (more time spend on the field the better the results are) but nothing happens... I don't understand how come English clubs does not want to loan English speaking players. I'm not expecting Arsenal or Chelsea but clubs like Watford, Brighton Fullham etc. I tried to loan other players from main squad and same situation...

Anyone knows what happens and WHY?

Thanks for answer but it's still not clear to me which one of player style is overall better
From one point of view single position star could be amazing (like right side defender) but at same time not many clubs today have this kind of solution in their squads
From the other side i got one Wonderteen who is trained from sweeper to offensive midfielder - his physical stats are insanely good but from technical aspect he is just mediocre at most not to mention his ability to marking, tackling and heading are 9/11/12 ... his value at this moment is calculated by game for 53KK euro ... without playing single game in main squad -age 18.

Just upload it to imgur - you don't need account there - copy link - replay to post You should press CTRL+P paste the link from imgur - link should appear in the post - save it and see the results

Hope it works for you

Ok i have more questions that i can't answer myself

1. CA=100 PA=200 Determination=20 which player will develop better (CA)
a) Single Position (like Center Forward or Center Defender)
b) Multi Purpose (like all position defender or all position supporter)

What i mean after same amount of time spend on the grass which one would have a better stats after while?

2.Value of player (Fame 10000)
I still don't get it how game is calculating a value of players
which one should be more expensive the multi purpose or just single minded one if both have same CA/PA?

3. Which player style is overall better for team in your opinion? Single position guy or a man who runs from end to end, from left to the right of the field ?

Hi

I'm playing FM15 Millwall mostly cause of nice logo

I was always wondering how to convince president of the club to invest into stadium
Many times before ( i had to start over) they come out of nowhere with this proposition, many times i convinced them to upgrade it. Once or twice They agreed to build new one. But I don't get it now ....
It's my 5th season Millwall advanced to Premiership, i won the 1st place in league last year, my job security is like 90-95 % my name is into Legend of this club, bank account is almost 450 000 000 Euro... yet AI does not see need to upgrade or Build new stadium because the fan numbers does not increase or something like that. How it can increase when you sold 15000 pass for 18600 places stadium, and every match stadium is full ...

Hi everyone, I'm not sure if that topic was discussed earlier if yes then I would be happy to get link to that topic, I couldn't find any. I don't know either if Im allowed to post it in this section (General FM Discussion) i could not find a better place for that.

My question concerns Hidden Attributes mainly in FM 2015 but i believe there was no major changes in further editions.

Does the hidden attributes are considered, during the calculation of PA and CA of the player ?
Before changes
After changes
Does the changes in those attributes affect CA ? for example If I lowered 4 abilities from 15 to 1 other values will increase? I'm using FMRTE to change PA, CA, Attributes, Contract etc.
Yeah my English is uhm... not so good.

Thank You.

Hello everyone, trough years I was playing FM15, someday i installed some kind of facepack and it was ok to me.

My disc died i reinstalled FM15 (I do not own FM 2020) and I'm curious
Can i Install "sortitoutsi_cutout_megapack_12.05" on FM 15 ???
Is there no compatible issues like non existing players faces or something?