That's not an improvement @Naufal Fadhullah Sidik. Not only have you cut-out the bottom bit of his chin, but there's also snow around his hair and no collar, plus the dimensions of the canvas are all wrong, so I'm rejecting this.

If you want to contribute quality cuts to the community, please read this thread which has plenty of hints and tips on what we expect from cut-outs

A better effort @Naufal Fadhullah Sidik, but cut dimensions should be 250x250. I'm re-opening both your cuts so that you can resize them as necessary. If you keep the shift button pressed when selecting the area to crop, the canvas size will automatically become a square

For this source, there's also a bit of snow in the right side of the hair. If you crop the source to around the hair and put that through remove.bg, I think you'd get an equally good cut with pretty much no snow. You can then crop as need

For the time being, it would be better if you do not upload any more cuts as completed until you improve your technique a bit. For now, while you're still starting out, it's better that you request the source and then put your draft cut in the comments for feedback. This way, we can guide you on how to improve your cutting technique and it saves me having to moderate cuts again and again.

please do admins, im not expert at photoshop thing or i just have to upload the full image only? so whoever have better skill can cut the image?

how about this?

You can upload the source image and wait for it to be cut, or if you want to, you can upload the cut-out you've done.



That's not 250x250 either, and there's hardly any hair details either, which is a pity since the source is good

then i will wait for someone, im not good with cutting the image , i just want my favorite player got the best portrait, btw thanks for your reply

oh i just try remove.bg as you said earlier, is this image acceptable ?

That's much better, wouldn't you say? And much easier too

yeah, but i got my image reduced in quality cause i use free version ahaha

Like I said, to get around this issue, all you need to do is to crop the source to around the hair and put that one through remove.bg instead of the full-size version.