Win a copy of FM24 in our Prediction League. Prizes are given out to the best predictor each month, so you have multiple chances to win.


Eric Portapotty
15 years ago
2 days ago
3,323
Tomas, at least you're not Gervais.
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
2 days ago
5,082
Premium
Jack Wilshere has had his best game this season today. He's world-class when he's on form. Hopefully they'll single out his performance on MOTD tonight.
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
2 days ago
5,082
Premium
Christ, we could have won this by four or five. Wasted so many chances today. Podolski's scooped it over from five yards out.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
That Cazorla dive is one of the worst I've seen. So little contact that it made it look like Ashley Young got fucking decapitated in comparison when he did that against Villa.
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
2 days ago
5,082
Premium
By Ninja | Permalink | On 08 December 2012 - 17:06 PM
That Cazorla dive is one of the worst I've seen. So little contact that it made it look like Ashley Young look got fucking decapitated in comparison when he did that against Villa.

Yeah, it was embarrassing to see. I hope Bould/ Wenger have a word with him about that.
VP.
13 years ago
1 month ago
25,271
Nothing worse than when your own side cheats to win.
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
2 days ago
5,082
Premium
By A Little Bit Of Merson Magic | Permalink | On 08 December 2012 - 19:43 PM
Nothing worse than when your own side cheats to win.

Yeah, I hate the fact we got a goal through a dive. Feels dirty. However, we dominated WBA from start to finish and were good for the win. Good to see us looking fresh again and playing well as a team.
Carroll.
15 years ago
3 years ago
3,361
By Ninja | Permalink | On 08 December 2012 - 17:06 PM
That Cazorla dive is one of the worst I've seen. So little contact that it made it look like Ashley Young got fucking decapitated in comparison when he did that against Villa.


Lets not get carried away.
K3V0
16 years ago
1 year ago
5,966
The FA need to start banning players for 3-5 games for diving and imposing heavy fines.

It will all soon stop!!
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
2 days ago
5,082
Premium
I was watching a stream on FOX Soccer and at half-time they said Cazorla should be given an eight-game suspension without pay.

I agree that the FA should be able to take retrospective action after the game though.
Shola
16 years ago
5 years ago
2,708
It's such a hard issue to tackle though, I thought there was actually very little difference in the dive between Cazorla and Oxlade-Chamberlain other than Reid missed and Macauley (Popov/Olsson?) actually made contact.

If Cazorla cut inside and does the exact same dive and Reid is a bit slower and Cazorla goes over his foot it's a stonewaller and no one would say it is a dive.

Where as I think Oxlade-Chamberlain goes past the defender sees the challenge and goes down, where as if the defender pulled out before making contact I reckon Oxlade-Chamberlain would already be on the floor and that would be considered to be a dive.
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
2 days ago
5,082
Premium
By Shola | Permalink | On 09 December 2012 - 02:09 AM
It's such a hard issue to tackle though, I thought there was actually very little difference in the dive between Cazorla and Oxlade-Chamberlain other than Reid missed and Macauley (Popov/Olsson?) actually made contact.

If Cazorla cut inside and does the exact same dive and Reid is a bit slower and Cazorla goes over his foot it's a stonewaller and no one would say it is a dive.

Where as I think Oxlade-Chamberlain goes past the defender sees the challenge and goes down, where as if the defender pulled out before making contact I reckon Oxlade-Chamberlain would already be on the floor and that would be considered to be a dive.

I get what you're saying but there was plenty of difference between the two. Cazorla went down under no contact at all, and Chamberlain was hacked down at full speed. One wasn't a penalty, one definitely was.
King Luis
17 years ago
3 months ago
3,111
Its hard to start banning players for diving as Shola has said, could end up with players simply losing their balance and getting banned for it.
K3V0
16 years ago
1 year ago
5,966
By King Luis | Permalink | On 09 December 2012 - 17:02 PM
Its hard to start banning players for diving as Shola has said, could end up with players simply losing their balance and getting banned for it.


Except when players dive it's usually followed by 785 rolls along with desperate clutching of their limbs like they've had a chainsaw taken to their knee or a turn to the referee to appeal for a foul or penalty.

When you lose your balance you don't tend to do those things.

How many cameras are at Premier League games these days?? You can see quite clearly Carzola has dived, just like you can see when Ashley Young does it or Danny Welbeck or Luis Suarez, they have to start banning players for it when it's clear they've taken a dive to try and con the referee.
King Luis
17 years ago
3 months ago
3,111
By K3V0 | Permalink | On 09 December 2012 - 07:10 AM
Except when players dive it's usually followed by 785 rolls along with desperate clutching of their limbs like they've had a chainsaw taken to their knee or a turn to the referee to appeal for a foul or penalty.

When you lose your balance you don't tend to do those things.

How many cameras are at Premier League games these days?? You can see quite clearly Carzola has dived, just like you can see when Ashley Young does it or Danny Welbeck or Luis Suarez, they have to start banning players for it when it's clear they've taken a dive to try and con the referee.


Even so its still far to subjective to be handing out bans imo.
K3V0
16 years ago
1 year ago
5,966
By King Luis | Permalink | On 09 December 2012 - 17:15 PM
Even so its still far to subjective to be handing out bans imo.


Most of the time you can clearly tell that somebody has dived, for example Suarez against Stoke and Welbeck against Wigan.

Carzola dived last night, even Arsene Wenger said so in a round about way, he should be banned for it.
Shola
16 years ago
5 years ago
2,708
By Telegram Sam | Permalink | On 09 December 2012 - 03:50 AM
I get what you're saying but there was plenty of difference between the two. Cazorla went down under no contact at all, and Chamberlain was hacked down at full speed. One wasn't a penalty, one definitely was.


I know there is a difference, I'm just saying if Steven Reid's legs were in a slightly different position, the Cazorla penalty would be a stonewaller as well. I'm assuming Cazorla was hoping Reid would clip him as he cut inside.

Basically the problem is players looking to go down and attempting to draw contact to win a penalty, rather than looking to score/go past the player and being taken down.
jumberto
16 years ago
1 month ago
1,111
Agree with that Shola.

A lot of cheating goes on, banning people for diving when often it's subjective is a bit risky. Also, a lot of times when there's just the slightest contact, the attacking player decides a second or two later he will go down and people say 'Oh he touched him and knocked him off balance' when clearly, he didn't. That's not much different to a dive in my eyes. Other times there will be slight contact but you think 'yeah maybe that did cause him to go down'. People seem to use the 'there was contact' argument when it suits them depending which teams/players are involved. Which is right? I don't know. I probably do it myself. Infact I will now. One replay of that Welbeck incident showed enough contact from Al-Habsi's leg to cause him to trip as he stretched for the ball. It's not clear whether he dived or not really.

All teams have players who dive, there's a variety of techniques and some are more obvious than others and these players tend to get all the attention but it's not as simple as just banning anyone who gets caught. It's too subjective. Look at the hysterical reactions to the Torres red card against us, some people swear blind he dived and his fall was unnatural, where as others are adamant he was fouled.

What about the defenders who foul the player then protest their innocence and get away with it, or worse scream at the attacker for diving when he hasn't? These incidents are equally as bad but get zero attention.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
@MandyHenryMedia: In his briefing with the Sunday papers on Friday, Sir Alex hinted he may "go with experience" in the midfield today. #mufc

Oh fuck.
Dutton
17 years ago
3 months ago
1,101
jumberto
16 years ago
1 month ago
1,111
Apparently Tony Valencia posted somewhere 'are you ready for a surprise today' or something like that hinting he is starting too.
Sam
17 years ago
1 year ago
5,092
I've read that was apparently a fake. Not sure though.

Experience in midfield, Fergie? So it'll be Giggs and Scholes in centre midfield then.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
By jumberto | Permalink | On 09 December 2012 - 11:32 AM
Apparently Tony Valencia posted somewhere 'are you ready for a surprise today' or something like that hinting he is starting too.

Fake instagram apparently.

But either way, knowing Valencia, I imagine his idea of a surprise is an extra pair of socks for Christmas and a warm cup of ovaltine before bed.

He'd be my least likely candidate to don a handle bar mustache (/Bebe mask) and turn up undetected at the Etihad.
jumberto
16 years ago
1 month ago
1,111
Haha true.

I just had a text saying that he'd said it but I've looked and it does seem fake. He is supposed to be injured anyway.

So we've got no natural width and our most in form central midfielder is also injured. Fantastic.
Ninja
14 years ago
7 years ago
5,341
Hart, Zabaleta, Kompany (c), Nastasic, Clichy, Yaya Toure, Barry, Nasri, Silva, Aguero, Balotelli

Balotelli would have been my last choice to start of their strikers, but Silva's fit.

De Gea, Rafael, Evra, Ferdinand, Evans, Valencia, Rooney, Carrick, Young, RVP, Cleverley

Cleverley, De Gea, No Scholes or Giggs, Valencia was fit. \o/
Eric Portapotty
15 years ago
2 days ago
3,323
Fergie lying?

MIND GAMES
K3V0
16 years ago
1 year ago
5,966
I predict a 1-1 draw tonight.
Telegram Sam
15 years ago
2 days ago
5,082
Premium
I hope City completely dick on United today.
Sam
17 years ago
1 year ago
5,092
Very good starting lineup.
VP.
13 years ago
1 month ago
25,271
The defence has got mistake written right through it.

You'll need to Login to comment