I'm afraid a lot of these simply aren't improvements @revivalm0de.

Compare the current cut with this one - it's clear the older image is sharper, crisper and more clear, has more hair details, has smoother edges and is simply a better representation of what the player looks like.

I urge you to check the current megapack cut to see if there is any point in making a new cut for the person. We aim to focus on those which are really necessary, i.e. those which are missing or those whose current cuts are old, lacking in quality or who look significantly different than the present person's look. We're looking for images which are improvements and not just images which are taken more recently, because they doesn't necessarily mean they are of the required quality. 

Well, i'm just trying to help. 

Nevermind then, i'm going to make sure i never try again.

There's nothing wrong at all with trying to help, but a lot of the players you've cut already have recent, high quality cutouts, and the sources you've chosen to cut seem to be low quality/low resolution, meaning any cutout made from them will be blurrier or lower quality than the existing cutouts. It also appears that you've stretched/squashed the proportions of some of the cutouts, so the player's face is too wide or too narrow.

To start with, I'd recommend cutting players who don't already have recent or high quality cutouts - there are plenty of players in the FM database with cutouts from 5 years ago or more - and uploading the cutouts one at a time so it's easier to give feedback on areas you can improve upon. Nobody's cutouts were perfect when they first started - me and mons included 😉 - and I'm sure your cutouts will get better with practice.

I'm sorry you feel that way, but there isn't really a good way to tell somebody their work isn't good enough. Perhaps I might have appeared harsh, which wasn't my intention. 

I certainly appreciate the enthusiasm and the effort, but if we don't give you feedback on how you can improve your cutting technique, then you'll keep producing cuts which aren't going to be added into the megapack, which would be a waste of your time, no? It's really in your interest at the end of the day to try and make sure that the time you're spending on cutting images gives the best possible output. I don't want you, or anybody else, to spend time cutting images which won't be added to the megapack, because what's the point in that?

This was not a criticism of your cutting technique. But when deciding to cut an image, choosing the source image is equally as important as your cutting technique. A cut can only be as good as the source it's coming from, and if it's a poor source, it'll be very hard to produce a quality cut from it. And I suspect the sources weren't very good.

At the end of the day, I don't believe this

is better than this

Would you disagree?