Feed
Football Manager 2020 is available to Play Now! Buy now, play instantly. Get these essential add ons to enhance Football Manager 2020 Want updated squads for FM20? We have the worlds biggest FM2020 Data Update. 34 seconds ago
Qvordrup commented on: Request Thread (FANTASY, ALTERNATIVE and ANYTHING NOT IN THE OFFICIAL FM DATABASE)
5 minutes ago
LGH11 commented on: (WIP) England Down To Level 10 With FA Competitions
9 minutes ago
crackvictor commented on: FM20 Adboard Patch - V1.0 Out Now!!!
9 minutes ago
Qvordrup commented on: Request Thread (ONLY TEAMS, COMPS and NATIONS THAT ARE IN THE OFFICIAL FM DATABASE)
14 minutes ago
Qvordrup commented on: FM2020 Licensing and Real Name Fix File v2.0 for FM20.3.0 [released on 20/02/2020]
15 minutes ago
manu74 commented on: Schweigi's Standard Logos
23 minutes ago
mons commented on: Please help- trouble getting any skins, logos etc to work
33 minutes ago
Ben Getty commented on: Please help- trouble getting any skins, logos etc to work
38 minutes ago
MMXX commented on: Schweigi's Standard Logos
45 minutes ago
MMXX commented on: FM2020 Licensing and Real Name Fix File v2.0 for FM20.3.0 [released on 20/02/2020]
48 minutes ago
Tommy Hughes commented on: FM 2020 FLUT skin dark - Version 1.7
49 minutes ago
mihataaa commented on: SS Fantasy Kits ONLY Thread (NO REAL KITS)
51 minutes ago
flut commented on: FM 2020 FLUT skin dark - Version 1.7
56 minutes ago
mons commented on: Image finder thread - assistance in finding a source image
58 minutes ago
Chetan K Paul commented on: FM20 Adboard Patch - V1.0 Out Now!!!
1 hour ago
crackvictor commented on: FM20 Adboard Patch - V1.0 Out Now!!!
1 hour ago
g0ofyy commented on: FM 2020 FLUT skin dark - Version 1.7
1 hour ago
A new version of our data update was released with 9583 changes from 58 contributors.
1 hour ago
mickbhoy commented on: Image finder thread - assistance in finding a source image
1 hour ago
manu74 commented on: Request Thread (ONLY TEAMS, COMPS and NATIONS THAT ARE IN THE OFFICIAL FM DATABASE)
1 hour ago
rioblahbloh commented on: Request Thread (ONLY TEAMS, COMPS and NATIONS THAT ARE IN THE OFFICIAL FM DATABASE)
1 hour ago
A11_Smithy commented on: Reviving the Sleeping Giant
2 hours ago
johnnfaf commented on: Unstoppable 4-2-3-1
2 hours ago
A new version of our data update was released with 9576 changes from 58 contributors.
2 hours ago
attlee74 commented on: 3D Template Kits Thread for FM20 only
2 hours ago
crackvictor commented on: FM20 Adboard Patch - V1.0 Out Now!!!
2 hours ago
Kun Aguero commented on: Reviving the Sleeping Giant
2 hours ago
Hajdu─Źki sin commented on: 3D Official Kits Thread
2 hours ago
Grimnir commented on: The TV Thread
2 hours ago
crackvictor commented on: FM20 Adboard Patch - V1.0 Out Now!!!
Type
Improvement
Date Requested
16 Oct 2016 18:55:35
Requested By
Player
Marvin Zeegelar
Player ID
37005651
View Existing Cuts
Current Status
Completed
Date Completed
17 Oct 2016 12:27:14
Completed By
Moderate Request
Discussion
It's debatable whether this would be an improvement

As posted elsewhere for a similar reason, the current megapack image was only created a couple of months or so ago and it's cut from a high-quality source. While your source is good (and I wish all players had source images as good and easy to cut), I just don't see the point in having a slightly different cut to the existing megapack version and I would much rather see cutters spending time on genuine improvements and missing images.

Apart from the source quality, you should also keep in mind the existing megapack image when making a request. Just because it's a newer image doesn't necessarily mean it's an improvement. I'm not rejecting it, but I doubt whether I'd consider any resulting cut for inclusion into the MP. Just letting you know so you keep it in mind for any future requests

«This comment has been edited»
It's debatable whether this would be an improvement

As posted elsewhere for a similar reason, the current megapack image was only created a couple of months or so ago and it's cut from a high-quality source. While your source is good (and I wish all players had source images as good and easy to cut), I just don't see the point in having a slightly different cut to the existing megapack version and I would much rather see cutters spending time on genuine improvements and missing images.

Apart from the source quality, you should also keep in mind the existing megapack image when making a request. Just because it's a newer image doesn't necessarily mean it's an improvement. I'm not rejecting it, but I doubt whether I'd consider any resulting cut for inclusion into the MP. Just letting you know so you keep it in mind for any future requests


Thanks mons and I will take everything you said into consideration
http://s7.postimg.org/t4rjwezm3/486377_429922187102298_901945610_n.jpg
Login to post a comment

Login Register